基于熵权和层次分析法的VOCs处理技术综合评价

张亚青; 王相; 孟凡荣; 张文睿; 焦甜甜; 张华伟; 梁鹏

PDF(667 KB)

中国环境科学 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (6) : 2946-2955.

环境影响评价与管理

基于熵权和层次分析法的VOCs处理技术综合评价

张亚青¹, 王相², 孟凡荣³, 张文睿², 焦甜甜¹, 张华伟¹, 梁鹏¹

作者信息 +

Comprehensive evaluation of VOCs processing technology based on entropy weight method and analytic hierarchy process

ZHANG Ya-qing¹, WANG Xiang², MENG Fan-rong³, ZHANG Wen-rui², JIAO Tian-tian¹, ZHANG Hua-wei¹, LIANG Peng¹

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

针对化工行业所使用的VOCs控制技术，综合考虑了环境、经济、管理以及技术4个一级因素以及13个二级因素对化工企业中常用的VOCs控制技术进行综合评价，建立基于熵权法与层次分析法相结合的模糊综合评价模型，对9种VOCs末端治理技术进行量化分析评价.阐述了备选VOCs的排放控制技术筛选方法、指标体系的构建以及评价方法，最后以山东省青岛市化工企业为例，给出了模型的求解过程和评价结果.结果显示，催化燃烧技术在环境和经济方面优势明显，热力焚烧技术在经济方面优势显著，吸附技术在技术方面优势突出.综合考虑环境、经济、管理和技术四个方面，VOCs排放控制技术综合评价结果为：催化燃烧>热力焚烧>光催化≈吸附浓缩-燃烧>等离子体>膜分离>吸附>冷凝>生物降解>吸收.

Abstract

Aiming at the VOCs control technology used in chemical industry, the 4primary factors of environment, economy, management, and technology and 13 secondary factors were comprehensively considered to evaluate VOCs control technologies commonly used in chemical enterprises. A fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model based on entropy weight method and analytic hierarchy process was established for quantitatively analyze, and 9kinds of VOCs elimination technologies were evaluated. The selection method of VOCs control technologies, and the construction and evaluation method of index system were described. Finally, taking the chemical enterprises in Qingdao, Shandong Province as an example, the resolution process and evaluation results of the model were given. The results showed that catalytic combustion technology had significant environmental and economic advantages, while thermal incineration technology performed better in economic aspects. Considering the 4aspects of environment, economy, management and technology, the comprehensive evaluation results of VOCs emission control technology were as follows: catalytic combustion > thermal incineration > photocatalysis ≈ adsorption condense combustion > plasma > membrane separation > adsorption > condensation > biodegradation > absorption.

导出引用

张亚青, 王相, 孟凡荣, 张文睿, 焦甜甜, 张华伟, 梁鹏. 基于熵权和层次分析法的VOCs处理技术综合评价[J]. 中国环境科学. 2021, 41(6): 2946-2955

ZHANG Ya-qing, WANG Xiang, MENG Fan-rong, ZHANG Wen-rui, JIAO Tian-tian, ZHANG Hua-wei, LIANG Peng. Comprehensive evaluation of VOCs processing technology based on entropy weight method and analytic hierarchy process[J]. China Environmental Science. 2021, 41(6): 2946-2955

中图分类号： X511

参考文献

[1] 毛红梅,张凯山,第宝锋.四川省天然源VOCs排放量的估算和时空分布[J]. 中国环境科学, 2016,36(5):1289-1296. Mao H M, Zhang K S, Di B F. Studies on estimates of biogenic VOC emission and its temporal and spatial distribution in Sichuan[J]. China Environmental Science, 2016,36(5):1289-1296.
[2] 王瑞鹏,周颖,程水源,等.华北地区典型机场清单建立及空气质量影响[J]. 中国环境科学, 2020,40(4):1468-1476. Wang R P, Zhou Y, Cheng S Y, et al. The establishment of airports emission inventory and the air quality impacts for typical airports in North China[J]. China Environmental Science, 2020,40(4):1468-1476.
[3] 范西彩,张新民,张晓红,等.鹤壁市大气挥发性有机物源排放清单研究[J]. 中国环境科学, 2021,41(2):558-565. Fan X C, Zhang X M, Zhang X H, et al. Research on the emission inventory of volatile organic compounds in Hebi City, Henan Province.[J]. China Environmental Science, 2021,41(2):558-565.
[4] US EPA. Guidance for determining BACT under PSD[S/OL] [S].
[5] US EPRI. Economic evaluation of flue gas desulfurization systems[S].
[6] US IEA. Flue gas desulphurization-system performance[S].
[7] 孙现伟,邓双,朱云,等.大气污染物控制技术的评估方法研究[J]. 能源与环境, 2015,(6):39-42. Sun X W, Deng S, Zhu Y, et al. Research on the assessment method of air pollutant control technology[J]. Energy and environment, 2015, (6):39-42.
[8] 李佳羽,刘利民,韩建华,等.典型化工园区VOCs排放控制技术的评价[J]. 化工进展, 2016,35(4):1250-1256. Li J Y, Liu L M, Han J H, et al. Evaluation of VOCs emission control technologies in typical chemical industry park[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2016,35(4):1250-1256.
[9] 田静.新乡市典型工业VOCs控制技术综合评估分析[D]. 郑州:郑州大学, 2019. Tian J. Comprehensive evaluation and analysis of typical industrial VOCs control technology in Xinxiang city[D]. Zhengzhou:Zhengzhou University, 2019.
[10] 李文娟,董事壁,滕富华,等.化工园区企业VOCs排放治理技术的评价分析[J]. 资源与环境, 2017,43(9):197-199. Li W J, Dong S B, Teng F H, et al. Evaluation of VOCs emission treatment technologies in chemical industry park[J]. Resources and Environment, 2017,43(9):197-199.
[11] 王海林,王俊慧,祝春蕾,等.包装印刷行业挥发性有机物控制技术评估与筛选[J]. 环境科学, 2014,35(7):2503-2507. Wang H L, Wang J H, Zhu C L, et al. Evaluation and selection of VOCs treatment technologies in packaging and printing industry[J]. Environmental Science, 2014,35(7):2503-2507.
[12] 阿克木×吾马尔,蔡思翌,赵斌,等.油品储运行业挥发性有机物排放控制技术评估[J]. 化工环保, 2015,35(1):64-68. Akemu W, Cai S Y, Zhao B, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of volatile organic compounds control technologies for oil storage and transportation[J]. Environmental Protection of Chemical Industry, 2015,35(1):64-68.
[13] 席富娟.长三角地区石化行业大气污染物排放状况及VOCs控制技术分析[D]. 杭州:浙江大学, 2018. Xi F J. Analysis of pollutants emission status and evaluation of VOCs control technologies for petrochemical industry in Yangtzeriver delta[D]. Hangzhou:Zhejiang University, 2018.
[14] 王灿,席劲瑛,胡洪营,等.挥发性有机物控制技术评价指标体系初探[J]. 化工环保, 2011,31(1):73-76. Wang C, Xi J Y, Hu H Y, et al. Evaluation system of volatile organic compound control technology[J]. Environmental Protection of Chemical Industry, 2011,31(1):73-76.
[15] 汪佳.基于灰色评价法的石化行业VOCs治理技术评估研究[J]. 中国石油和化工标准与质量, 2017,37(5):82-84. Wang J. Evaluation of VOCs control technology in petrochemical industry based on grey evaluation method[J]. Standards and Quality of China Petroleum and Chemical Industry, 2017,37(5):82-84.
[16] Ramadan M, Effat H A. Geospatial modeling for a sustainable urban development zoning mapusing AHP in Ismailia Governorate, Egypt[J]. The Egyptian Journal of Remote Sensing and Space Science, 2021,24:191-202.
[17] Solangi Y A, Longsheng C, Shah S A A. Assessing and overcoming the renewable energy barriers for sustainable development in Pakistan:An integrated AHP and fuzzy TOPSIS approach[J]. Renewable Energy, 2021,173:209-222.
[18] Jose C, Grace K S V. A new approach for accurate path prediction using multiple prediction system[J]. Materials Today:Proceeding, 2020,24:1749-1757.
[19] Liu L, Jong de M, Huang Y. Assessing the administrative practice of environmental protection performance evaluation in China:the case of Shenzhen[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2016,134:51-60.
[20] Streets D G, Yu C, Bergin M H, et al. Modeling study of air pollution due to the manufacture of export goods in China's Pearl River Delta[J]. Environmental Science & Technology, 2006,40(7):2099-2107.
[21] Li Y Y, Huang S, Yin C X, et al. Construction and countermeasure discussion on government performance evaluation model of air pollution control:A case study from Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2020,254:120072.
[22] 尚天成,高彬彬,李翔鹏,等.基于层次分析法和熵权法的城市土地集约利用评价[J]. 电子科技大学学报(社科版), 2009,11(6):6-9. Shang T C, Gao B B, Li X P, et al. Urban land intensive utilization evaluation based on AHP and entropy method[J]. Journal of UESTC (Social Sciences Edition), 2009,11(6):6-9.
[23] Wu G D, Duan K F, Zuo J, et al. Integrated sustainability assessment of public rental housing community based on a hybrid method of AHP-entropy weight and cloud model[J]. Sustainability, 2017,9:2-25.
[24] Cui X L, Wu X J, He X J, et al. Regional suitability of virtual water strategy:evaluating with an integrated water-ecosystem-economy index[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2018,199:659-667.
[25] 席劲瑛,武俊良,胡洪营,等.工业VOCs气体处理技术应用状况调查分析[J]. 中国环境科学, 2012,32(11):1955-1960. Xi J Y, Wu J L, Hu H Y, et al. Application status of industrial VOCs gas treatment techniques[J]. China Environmental Science, 2012, 32(11):1955-1960.
[26] 张永明,邓娟,梁健.工业源VOCs末端治理技术浅析及减排展望[J]. 环境影响评价, 2018,40(2):46-50. Zhang Y M, Deng J, Liang J. Analysis of end treatment technology of industrial source VOCs and its emission reduction prospects[J]. Environmental Impact Assessment, 2018,40(2):46-50.
[27] 王彦丽.VOCs有机废气处理技术的应用现状研究[J]. 黑龙江科学, 2020,11(8):154-155. Wang Y L. Progress about VOCs organic waste gas treatment technology[J]. Heilongjiang Science, 2020,11(8):154-155.
[28] Wu X C, Huang W W, Zhang Y X, et al. Characteristics and uncertainty of industrial VOCs emissions in China[J]. Aerosol and Air Quality Research, 2015,15(3):1045-1058.
[29] 吕建华,左华,李瑞芃,等.青岛市工业挥发性有机物治理的对策与建议[C]//中国环境科学学会、水性平台.2018全国VOCs监测与治理高峰论坛论文集.中国环境科学学会、水性平台:中国环境科学学会, 2018:6. Lv J H, Zuo H, Li R P, et al. The governance countermeasure and the suggestion of industrial volatile organic compounds in Qingdao[C]//Chinese Society of Environmental Sciences, Waterborne Platform. Proceedings of the 2018National VOCs Monitoring and Governance Summit Forum. Chinese Society of Environmental Sciences, Waterborne Platform:Chinese Society of Environmental Sciences, 2018:6.
[30] 黄薇薇.我国工业源挥发性有机化合物排放特征及其控制技术评估研究[D]. 杭州:浙江大学, 2016. Huang W. Characteristics of industrial VOCs emissions and evaluation of control technology in China[D]. Hangzhou:Zhejiang University, 2016.
[31] 王宇飞,刘昌新,程杰,等.工业VOCs经济手段和工程技术减排对比性分析[J]. 环境科学, 2015,(4):1507-1512. Wang Y F, Liu C X, Cheng J, et al. Comparison analysis of economic and engineering control of industrial VOCs[J]. Environmental Science. 2015,(4):1507-1512.
[32] 赵琪.工业源VOCs气体污染控制技术应用研究[J]. 化工管理, 2020,(23):64-65. Zhao Qi. Research on the application of VOCs pollution control technology from industrial sources[J]. Chemical Industry Management, 2020,(23):64-65.
[33] 沈达,刘金吉,周飞,等.化工企业VOCs治理评估指标体系的建立与应用[J]. 环境监控与预警, 2020,12(4):51-55. Shen D, Liu J J, Zhou F, et al. Construction and application of evaluation index system for VOCs Control in chemical enterprises[J]. Environmental Monitoring and Forewarning, 2020,12(4):51-55.
[34] 杜小娟,孙娟.北京市汽车整车制造VOCs控制技术评估及对策建议[J]. 节能与环保, 2017,(3):56-59. Du X J, Sun J. Evaluation and suggestions on VOCs control technology for automobile manufacturing in Beijing[J]. Energy Saving and Environmental Protection, 2017,(3):56-59.
[35] 李瑞芃,吕建华,付飞,等.青岛市重点工业行业挥发性有机物对二次污染物生成的贡献及健康风险研究[J]. 环境污染与治理, 2020,42(2):212-217. Li R P, Lv J H, Fu F, et al. The contributions to secondary pollutants and health risk of volatile organic compounds in major industries of Qingdao[J]. Environmental Pollution and Control, 2020,42(2):212-217.
[36] 吕建华,李瑞荒,付飞,等.青岛市挥发性有机物排放清单及重点行业排放特征研究[J]. 中国环境管理, 2019,(1):60-66. Lv J H, Li R P, Fu F, et al. Emission inventory of volatile organic compounds and emission characteristics of key industries in Qingdao[J]. Environmental Management in China, 2019,(1):60-66.