清洁取暖政策试点的空气质量改善效应评估——基于三批试点地级市的准自然实验

Abstract
Figure/Table
References
Related Citation (15)

Download: PDF (730 KB) HTML (0 KB)
Export: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)

Abstract Based on the balanced panel data of 321 prefecture level cities from 2014 to 2019, the multi-period Differences-in-Differences (DID) approach was used to quantify the air pollution improvement effect of the Clean Heating Policy Pilot (CHPP) in China. The results showed that the CHPP significantly reduced air pollution and improved the air quality of pilot cities. On average, the air quality index (AQI) of the pilot cities was significantly lower than that of the non-pilot cities by 4.12; AQI, PM_2.5, PM₁₀ and SO₂ decreased by about 5.49%, 11.47%, 12.65% and 35.66% respectively. The result remained consistent after a series of robustness tests. The internal mechanism of the CHPP to improve urban air quality was that the CHPP changed the heating energy structure of urban residents and reduced the emission of sulfide and inhalable particulate matter. Therefore, during the "14th five-year plan" period, it is recommended that the government should expand the implementation scope of CHPP, increase financial investment, promote fiscal expenditure efficiency, reduce the costs of clean energy and promote the universal adoption of clean energy.

Key words： clean heating air quality policy evaluation energy structure PM_2.5 DID

Received: 22 May 2023

PACS:	F299.24
	X51

	Service

	E-mail this article
	Add to my bookshelf
	Add to citation manager
	E-mail Alert
	RSS
	Articles by authors
	WANG Yu
	LIU Wen-zhang

Cite this article:

WANG Yu,LIU Wen-zhang. Evaluating the effect of Clean Heating Policy Pilot on air quality improvement: A quasi-experimental study based on three batches of pilot cities in China[J]. CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCECE, 2024, 44(1): 581-592.

URL:

http://www.zghjkx.com.cn/EN/ OR http://www.zghjkx.com.cn/EN/Y2024/V44/I1/581

[1]	人民日报.持续改善环境质量(深入学习贯彻党的十九届五中全会精神) [EB/OL].https://wap.peopleapp.com/article/6098433/6008700.2021-01-07/2023-05-17.People's Daily.Continuous improvement of environmental quality (implement the guiding principles of the fifth plenary session of the 19th Central Committee) [EB/OL].https://wap.peopleapp.com/article/6098433/6008700.2021-01-07/2023-05-17.
[2]	央广网.生态环境"环保账":2020年PM2.5平均浓度比2015年下降28.8% [EB/OL].https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1708504532726504064&wfr=spider&for=pc.2021-08-19/2023-05-17.CNR News.Ecological environment "environmental account":The average PM2.5concentration in 2020decreased by 28.8% compared to 2015[EB/OL].https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1708504532726504064&wfr=spider&for=pc.2021-08-19/2023-05-17.
[3]	Zhang Y, Li W, Wu F.Does energy transition improve air quality? Evidence derived from China's Winter Clean Heating Pilot (WCHP) project [J].Energy, 2020,206:118130.
[4]	沈坤荣,金刚.中国地方政府环境治理的政策效应——基于"河长制"演进的研究[J].中国社会科学, 2018,(5):92-115,206.Shen K R, Jin G.The policy effects of the environmental governance of Chinese local governments:A study based on the progress of the river chief system [J].Social Sciences in China, 2018(5):92-115,206.
[5]	中国政府网.关于开展中央财政支持北方地区冬季清洁取暖试点工作的通知[EB/OL].http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2017-05/20/content_5195490.htm.2017-05-20/2023-05-17.The State Council of the People's Republic of China.Notice on carrying out the pilot work of the central government financial support for clean energy in winter heating in north China [EB/OL].http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2017-05/20/content_5195490.htm.2017-05-20/2023-05-17.
[6]	IESPlaza综能网.三年493亿元奖补资金中央财政对清洁取暖后续支持如何? [EB/OL].https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1687412716023477009&wfr=spider&for=pc.2020-12-29/2023-05-17.IESPlaza.A 49.3-billion-yuan fund for rewards and subsidies over three years:what is the follow-up support of the central government for clean heating? [EB/OL].https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1687412716023477009&wfr=spider&for=pc.2020-12-29/2023-05-17.
[7]	周卫青,吴华成,李朋,等.基于实测的北方地区不同清洁取暖方式环境效益对比研究[J].环境污染与防治, 2021,43(4):416-420.Zhou W Q, Wu H C, li P, et al.Comparative study environmental benefits of different clean heating modes in northern China based on testing [J].Environmental Pollution & Control, 2021,43(4):416-420.
[8]	姚华,黄云,徐敬英,等.我国北方地区清洁供暖技术现状与问题探讨[J].中国科学院院刊, 2020,35(9):1177-1188.Yao H, Huang Y, XU J Y, et al.Technology status and discussion on challenges of clean heating in Northern China [J].Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2020,35(9):1177-1188.
[9]	Wang Z, Li C, Cui C, et al.Cleaner heating choices in northern rural China:Household factors and the dual substitution policy [J].Journal of Environmental Management, 2019,249:109433.
[10]	Xie W, Chen C, Li F, et al.Key factors of rural households' willingness to pay for cleaner heating in Hebi:A case study in northern China [J].Sustainability, 2021,13(2):633.
[11]	晋荣荣,李世平,南灵.农户清洁取暖采纳意愿的影响因素分析——基于汾渭平原微观调查数据[J].干旱区资源与环境, 2021,35(5):41-47.Jin R R, LI S P, Nan L.Analysis on factors influencing farmer's willingness to adopt clean heating [J].Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment, 2021,35(5):41-47.
[12]	Su D, Zhou W, Gu Y, et al.Individual motivations underlying the adoption of cleaner residential heating technologies:evidence from Nanjing, China [J].Journal of Cleaner Production, 2019,224:142-150.
[13]	谢伦裕,常亦欣,蓝艳.北京清洁取暖政策实施效果及成本收益量化分析[J].中国环境管理, 2019,11(3):87-93.Xie L Y, Cang Y X, Lan Y.The effectiveness and cost-benefit analysis of clean heating program in Beijing [J].Chinese Journal of Environmental Management, 2019,11(3):87-93.
[14]	Li Y, Yuan X, Tang Y, et al.Integrated assessment of the environmental and economic effects of "coal-to-gas conversion" project in rural areas of northern China [J].Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2020,27:14503-14514.
[15]	Mao X, Guo X, Chang Y, et al.Improving air quality in large cities by substituting natural gas for coal in China:changing idea and incentive policy implications [J].Energy Policy, 2005,33(3):307-318.
[16]	Lin B, Zhu J.Is the implementation of energy saving and emission reduction policy really effective in Chinese cities? A policy evaluation perspective [J].Journal of Cleaner Production, 2019,220:1111-1120.
[17]	熊艳,廖文军,王岭."煤改气、电"政策的空气污染治理效应研究[J].财经论丛, 2021,(3):103-112.Xiong Y, Liao W J, Wang L.A study on air pollution governance effect of the "Coal-to-Gas/Electricity" [J].Policy Collected Essays on Finance and Economics, 2021,(3):103-112.
[18]	王恰,郑世林."2+26"城市联合防治行动对京津冀地区大气污染物浓度的影响[J].中国人口·资源与环境, 2019,29(9):51-62.Wang Q, Zheng S L.Impact of joint prevention and control action on atmospheric pollutant concentration in ‘2+ 26’ cities [J].China Population, Resources and Environment, 2019,29(9):51-62.
[19]	宋玲玲,何军,武娟妮,等.我国北方地区冬季清洁取暖试点实施评估研究[J].环境保护, 2019,47(9):64-68.Song L L, He J, Wu J N, et al.Study on the implementation evaluation of clean heating pilot city in Northern China [J].Environmental Protection, 2019,47(9):64-68.
[20]	Zeng J.Did policy experimentation in China always seek efficiency? A case study of Wenzhou financial reform in 2012[J].Journal of Contemporary China, 2015,24(92):338-356.
[21]	吴怡频,陆简.政策试点的结果差异研究——基于2000年至2012年中央推动型试点的实证分析[J].公共管理学报, 2018,15(1):58-70,156.Wu Y P, Lu J.Explaining the different outcomes of policy experiments:an empirical study on the policy experiments sponsored by central government agencies between 2000 and 2012[J].Journal of Public Management, 2018,15(1):58-70,156.
[22]	姚连营.政策试点成效的影响因素研究——基于浙江省417项试点的实证分析[J].甘肃行政学院学报, 2019,(5):50-60,126-127.Yao L Y.Study on the influencing factors of the result of policy pilot——An empirical analysis based on 417 pilot programs in Zhejiang province [J].Journal of Gansu Administration Institute, 2019, (5):50-60,126-127.
[23]	王志刚,朱慧.中国财政政策乘数效应分析[J].财政科学, 2021,(2):14-25.Wang Z G, Zhu H.The analysis of Chinese fiscal policy multiplier effect [J].Fiscal Science, 2021,(2):14-25.
[24]	张开,龚六堂.多部门模型中的政府支出乘数[J].华中科技大学学报(社会科学版), 2017,31(3):98-107.Zhang K, Gong L J.Government spending multiplier in a multi-sector model [J].Journal of Huazhong University of Science and Technology (Social Science Edition), 2017,31(3):98-107.
[25]	丁海,石大千,张卫东.环境治理谁主沉浮:中央还是地方?——基于央地博弈对比的测算分析[J].南方经济, 2020,(3):86-104.Ding H, Shi D Q, Zhang W D.Who is the master of environmental governance:the central or the local?——Calculation and analysis based on the comparison of the central-local game[J].South China Journal of Economics, 2020,(3):86-104.
[26]	谢光华,韩丹妮,郝颖,等.政府补贴、资本投资与经济增长质量[J].管理科学学报, 2020,23(5):24-53.Xie G H, Han D N, Hao Y, et al.Government subsidy, capital investment and economic growth quality [J].Journal of Management Sciences in China, 2020,23(5):24-53.
[27]	周文婷,吴一平.基于财政补贴视角的隐性担保对信贷约束的影响[J].财政研究, 2020,(10):42-56.Zhou W T, Wu Y P.The impact of implicit guarantees on credit constraints from the perspective of fiscal subsidies [J].Public Finance Research, 2020,(10):42-56.
[28]	孙德超,曹志立.政府引导低碳消费方式的障碍与消解路径探析[J].福建师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2015,(1):18-22,166.Sun D C Chao Z L.On the facing obstacles and resolutions of the government guiding low carbon consumption [J].Journal of Fujian Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 2015, (1):18-22,166.
[29]	Chen S, Chi H.Analysis of the environmental effects of the clean heating policy in Northern China [J].Sustainability, 2021,13(12):6695.
[30]	Weng Z, Han E, Wu Y, et al.Environmental and economic impacts of transitioning to cleaner heating in Northern China [J].Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2021,172:105673.
[31]	Xu S, Ge J.Sustainable shifting from coal to gas in North China:An analysis of resident satisfaction [J].Energy Policy, 2020,138:111296.
[32]	散煤治理研究课题组.中国散煤综合治理研究报告2020[M].北京:北京大学能源研究院, 2021.Dispersed Coal Management Research Group.China dispersed coal management report 2020[R].Beijing:Institute of Energy Research, Peking University, 2021.
[33]	魏巍贤,马喜立.能源结构调整与雾霾治理的最优政策选择[J].中国人口·资源与环境, 2015,25(7):6-14.Wei W X, Ma X L.Optimal policy for energy structure adjustment and haze governance in China [J].China Population, Resources and Environment, 2015,25(7):6-14.
[34]	张保留,罗宏,吕连宏,等.京津冀区域清洁取暖的支付意愿和影响因素[J].中国环境科学, 2021,41(1):490-496.Zhang B L, Luo H, LÜ L H, et al.The willingness to pay for clean heating and its influencing factors in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei Region [J].China Environmental Science, 2021,41(1):490-496.
[35]	Gong Y, Cai B, Sun Y.Perceived fiscal subsidy predicts rural residential acceptance of clean heating:Evidence from an indoor-survey in a pilot city in China [J].Energy Policy, 2020,144:111687.
[36]	中国政府网.财政部:让保蓝天与保温暖同行[EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2018-08/31/content_5318042.htm.2018-08-31/2023-11-18.The State Council of the People's Republic of China.The finance ministry:Keep the sky blue and keep the warmth together [EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2018-08/31/content_5318042.htm.2018-08-31/2023-11-18.
[37]	住房和城乡建设部.中国城市建设统计年鉴2014~2020[M].北京:中国统计出版社, 2020.Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development.Statistical yearbook of China's urban construction 2014~2020[M].Beijing:China Statistics Press, 2020.
[38]	国家统计局.中国城市统计年鉴2014~2020[M].北京:中国统计出版社, 2020.National Bureau of Statistics.China urban statistical yearbook 2014~2020[M].Beijing:China Statistics Press, 2020.
[39]	中国环境监测总站.空气质量预报系统[EB/OL].http://www.cnemc.cn/sssj/.2023-11-18/2023-11-18.China National Environmental Monitoring Centre.air-quality forecasting system [EB/OL].http://www.cnemc.cn/sssj/.2023-11-18/2023-11-18.
[40]	Beck T, Levine R, Levkov A.Big bad banks? The winners and losers from bank deregulation in the United States [J].The Journal of Finance, 2010,65(5):1637-67.
[41]	中国政府网.空气污染四大主要来源为燃煤、工业、机动车、扬尘,占比达到90%左右[EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2019-03/11/content_5372975.htm.2019-03-11/2023-05-17.The State Council of the People's Republic of China.The four main sources of air pollution are coal burning, industry, motor vehicles, and dust, accounting for about 90% [EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2019-03/11/content_5372975.htm.2019-03-11/2023-05-17.
[42]	中国政府网.《大气污染防治行动计划》实施情况中期评估报告[EB/OL].https://www.mee.gov.cn/ywdt/hjywnews/201607/t20160706_357205.shtml.2016-07-06/2023-05-17.The State Council of the People's Republic of China.Mid-term evaluation report on the implementation of the《Action Plan for Prevention and Control of Air Pollution [EB/OL].https://www.mee.gov.cn/ywdt/hjywnews/201607/t20160706_357205.shtml.2016-07-06/2023-05-17.
[43]	何凌云,马青山.智慧城市试点能否提升城市创新水平?——基于多期DID的经验证据[J].财贸研究, 2021,32(3):28-40.He L Y, Ma Q S.Can smart city pilots promote level of urban innovation? Empirical evidence based on multi-period DID [J].Finance and Trade Research, 2021,32(3):28-40.
[44]	澎湃新闻.又见雾炮车猛喷环境监测点[EB/OL].https://m.thepaper.cn/baijiahao_13908386.2021-08-06/2023-05-17.The paper.The fog cannon truck was seen again blasting the environmental monitoring site cannon truck [EB/OL].https://m.thepaper.cn/baijiahao_13908386.2021-08-06/2023-05-17.
[45]	黎文靖,郑曼妮.空气污染的治理机制及其作用效果——来自地级市的经验数据[J].中国工业经济, 2016,(4):93-109.Li W J, Zheng M N.Governance mechanism of air pollution and its effects——Evidence from Chinese prefecture-level cities [J].China Industrial Economics, 2016,(4):93-109.
[46]	杨野,常懿心.地方政府驻地迁移与财政支出效率[J].经济评论, 2021,(4):131-144.Yang Y, Chang Y X.Local government resident relocation and fiscal expenditure efficiency [J].Economic Review, 2021,(4):131-144.