基于输出系数法的农业面源氮磷排放特征分析

苟婷; 裴德富; 梁荣昌; 佘磊; 杨珺; 马千里; 赵学敏; 赵瑞; 姚玲爱

PDF(2279 KB)

中国环境科学 ›› 2023, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (12) : 6539-6550.

环境生态

基于输出系数法的农业面源氮磷排放特征分析

苟婷¹, 裴德富^1,2, 梁荣昌¹, 佘磊¹, 杨珺³, 马千里¹, 赵学敏¹, 赵瑞¹, 姚玲爱¹

作者信息 +

Analysis of nitrogen and phosphorus emissions from agricultural non-point sources based on improved output coefficient method

GOU Ting¹, PEI De-fu^1,2, LIANG Rong-chang¹, SHE Lei¹, YANG Jun³, MA Qian-li¹, ZHAO Xue-min¹, ZHAO Rui¹, YAO Ling-ai¹

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

为研究东江源头区农业面源氮磷负荷情况,利用改进的输出系数模型(ECM)对2020年东江源头区农业面源氮磷排放特征进行了探讨.结果表明:(1)东江源头区农业面源污染物总氮(TN)和总磷(TP)负荷量分别是4884.23t/a和591.85t/a, TN污染负荷是TP污染负荷的8.25倍,其中高于源头区TN平均负荷量的乡镇依次为留车镇、文峰乡、晨光镇、南桥镇、吉潭镇、丹溪乡和澄江镇,高于源头区TP平均负荷量的乡镇依次为晨光镇、留车镇、南桥镇、文峰乡、丹溪乡、菖蒲乡和吉潭镇.(2)氮磷污染负荷强度与负荷量不同,且表现出一定的空间差异性.污染负荷量较高分别为留车镇和晨光镇,但负荷强度最高分别为南桥镇和菖蒲乡.TN负荷强度较高的依次为南桥镇、菖蒲乡、晨光镇、留车镇和项山乡,均高于源头区TN平均负荷强度2.88t/(km²×a);TP负荷强度较高的依次为菖蒲乡、南桥镇、晨光镇、丹溪乡、留车镇和罗珊乡,均高于源头区TP平均负荷强度0.36t/(km²×a).(3)不同污染源类型对氮磷排放的贡献率不一致,TN污染表现为土地利用>农村生活>畜禽养殖,TP污染表现为畜禽养殖>土地利用>农村生活.其中氮源中土地利用污染占比为37.67%~80.29%,主要分布在长宁镇、桂竹帽镇、三标乡、水源乡、文峰乡等;磷源中畜禽养殖污染占比44.75%~70.71%,主要分布在菖蒲乡、晨光镇、罗珊乡、南桥镇、丹溪乡、龙廷乡和留车镇.东江源头区各乡镇氮磷面源污染特征不同,其治理手段和目标也不尽相同,对于菖蒲乡、晨光镇、南桥镇等需切实解决畜禽养殖规划性不强,部分养殖户选址不合理,粪污治理设施普及率和资源化利用水平低等问题;对于留车镇、澄江镇、吉潭镇等应大力推进小型农村污水处理设施建设,完善生活污水处理措施;对于文峰乡、三标乡、水源乡等乡镇需制定合理的施肥方案,避免化肥过量施用及利用率低的问题.

Abstract

To study the nitrogen and phosphorus loadings from agricultural surface sources in the source area of Dongjiang River, the characteristics of nitrogen and phosphorus emissions from agricultural surface sources in the source area of Dongjiang River in 2020 were explored using an improved output coefficient model (ECM). The results show that: (1) the loads of total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) of agricultural surface source pollutants in the source area of Dongjiang River were 4884.23t/a and 591.85t/a, respectively, and the TN pollution load was 8.25 times of the TP pollution load. Among the townships with higher than the average TN load were Liuche Township, Wenfeng Township, Chenguang Township, Nanqiao Township, Jitan Township, Danxi Township and Chengjiang Township, higher than the TP average load of the township were Chenguang, Liuche Township, Nanqiao Township, Wenfeng Township, Danxi Township, Calamus Township and Jitan Township. (2) Nitrogen and phosphorus pollution load intensity and load amount was different, and showed spatial variability. The higher pollution load was Liuche Township and Chenguang Township respectively, but the highest load intensity was Nanqiao Township and Calamus Township respectively. The higher TN load intensity was in the order of Nanqiao Township, Calamus Township, Chenguang Township, Liuche Township and Xiangshan Township, which all higher than the average TN load intensity of 2.88t/(km²×a) in the source area; the higher TP load intensity was in the order of Calamus Township, Nanqiao Township, Chenguang Township, Danxi Township, Liuche Township and Luoshan Township, which all higher than the source area TP average load intensity of 0.36t/(km²×a). (3) The contribution of different source types to nitrogen and phosphorus emissions was not consistent, TN pollution was manifested as land use > rural life > livestock breeding, TP pollution was manifested as livestock breeding > land use > rural life. Among the nitrogen sources, land use pollution accounted for 37.67%~80.29%, mainly distributed in Changning Township, Guizhumat Township, Sanbiao Township, Water Source Township, Wenfeng Township; phosphorus sources of livestock breeding pollution accounted for 44.75%~70.71%, mainly distributed in Calamus Township, Chenguang Township, Luoshan Township, Nanqiao Township, Danxi Township, Longting Township and Liuche Township. Based on different characteristics of nitrogen and phosphorus non-point source pollution in the source area of Dongjiang River, the treatment methods were also different. For the townships were seriously polluted by livestock breeding, which should to solve the problems of poor planning of livestock breeding, unreasonable site selection and low level of resource utilization. The townships were seriously polluted by rural living pollution which should vigorously promote the construction of small rural sewage treatment facilities and improve the living sewage treatment measures. Other townships need to develop a reasonable fertilizer application program to avoid excessive application of chemical fertilizers. This study has important practical significance for improving the continuous emission reduction of agricultural non-point source pollution and ensuring the safety of water supply in Dongjiang River.

导出引用

苟婷, 裴德富, 梁荣昌, 佘磊, 杨珺, 马千里, 赵学敏, 赵瑞, 姚玲爱. 基于输出系数法的农业面源氮磷排放特征分析[J]. 中国环境科学. 2023, 43(12): 6539-6550

GOU Ting, PEI De-fu, LIANG Rong-chang, SHE Lei, YANG Jun, MA Qian-li, ZHAO Xue-min, ZHAO Rui, YAO Ling-ai. Analysis of nitrogen and phosphorus emissions from agricultural non-point sources based on improved output coefficient method[J]. China Environmental Science. 2023, 43(12): 6539-6550

中图分类号： X501

参考文献

[1] Nguyen H H, Recknagel F, Meyer W, et al. Comparison of the alternative models SOURCE and SWAT for predicting catchment streamflow, sediment and nutrient loads under the effect of land use changes[J]. Science of the Total Environment, 2019,662:254-265.
[2] Engebretsen A, Vogt R D, Bechmann M. SWAT model uncertainties and cumulative probability for decreased phosphorus loading by agricultural Best Management Practices[J]. Catena, 2019,175:154-166.
[3] Cheng X, Chen L D, Sun R H, et al. An improved export coefficient model to estimate non-point source phosphorus pollution risks under complex precipitation and terrain conditions[J]. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2018,25(21):20946-20955.
[4] 刘彬,吴卿,高辉巧.SWAT模型在香溪河流域非点源污染研究中的应用现状及进展[J]. 水资源开发与管理, 2018,(11):28-31. Liu B, Wu Q, Gao H Q. Application progress of SWAT model in non-point source pollution research in Xiangxi River Basin[J]. Water Resources Development and Management, 2018,(11):28-31.
[5] Cheng X, Chen L, Sun R, et al. Identification of regional water resource stress based on water quantity and quality: A case study in a rapid urbanization region of China[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2019,209:216-223.
[6] Johnes P J. Evaluation and management of the impact of land use change on the nitrogen and phosphorus land delivered to surface waters: the export coefficient modelling approach[J]. Journal of Hydrology, 1996,183(3/4):323-349.
[7] 蔡明,李怀恩,庄咏涛,等.改进的输出系数法在流域非点源污染负荷估算中的应用[J]. 水利学报, 2004,7(6):40-45. Cai M, Li H E, Zhuang Y T, et al. Application of modified export coefficient method in polluting load estimation of non-point source pollution[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2004,7(6):40-45.
[8] Ding X W, Shen Z Y, Hong Q, et al. Development and test of the export coefficient model in the upper reach of the Yangtze River[J]. Journal of Hydrology, 2010,383(3):233-244.
[9] 任玮,代超,郭怀成.基于改进输出系数模型的云南宝象河流域非点源污染负荷估算[J]. 中国环境科学, 2015,35(8):2400-2408. Ren W, Dai C, Guo H C. Estimation of pollution load from non-point source in Baoxianghe watershed based, Yunnan Province on improved export coefficient model[J]. China Environmental Science, 2015,35(8): 2400-2408.
[10] 贺赟,杨爱江,陈蔚洁,等.西南喀斯特山区典型流域农业非点源污染负荷及分布特征[J]. 水土保持研究, 2022,29(1):148-152. He Y, Yang A J, Chen W J, et al. Research on spatial characteristic sand the load of agricultural non-point source pollution in Karst area of southwestern China[J]. Research of Soil and Water Conservation, 2022,29(1):148-152.
[11] 丁洋,赵进勇,董飞,等.妫水河流域农业非点源污染负荷估算与分析[J]. 水利水电技术, 2020,51(1):139-146. Ding Y, Zhao J Y, Dong F, et al. Estimation and analysis of agricultural non-point source pollution load in Guishui River Watershed[J]. Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering, 2020,51(1):139-146.
[12] Chen X, Liu X, Peng W, et al. Non-Point Source Nitrogen and Phosphorus Assessment and Management Plan with an Improved Method in Data-Poor Regions[J]. Water, 2017,10(1):17.
[13] Shen Z, Hong Q, Yu H, et al. Parameter uncertainty analysis of non-point source pollution from different land use types[J]. Science of the Total Environment, 2010,408(8):1971-1978.
[14] 高田田,谢晖,万能胜,等.巢湖典型农村流域面源氮磷污染模拟及来源解析[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2022,41(11):2428-2438. Gao T T, Xie H, Wan N S, et al. Simulation and source analysis of nonpoint source nitrogen and phosphorus pollution export in a typical agricultural catchment draining to Chaohu Lake[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science, 2022,41(11):2428-2438.
[15] 薛利红,杨林章.面源污染物输出系数模型的研究进展[J]. 生态学杂志, 2009,28(4):755-761. Xue L H, Yang L Z. Research advances of export coefficient model for non-point source pollution[J]. Journal of Ecology, 2009,28(4):755-761.
[16] Beaulac M N, Reckhow K H. Anexamination of land use nutrient export relationships[J]. Water Resource Bulletin, 1982,18(6):1013-1024.
[17] Frink C R. Estimating nutrient exports to estuaries[J]. Journal of Environmental Quality, 1991,20(4):717-724.
[18] 郝桂珍,宋凤芝,徐利,等.基于输出系数模型的清水河上游农业非点源污染负荷估算[J]. 科学技术与工程, 2020,20(33):13919-13927. Hao G Z, Song F Z, Xu L, et al. Estimation of pollution loads from agricultural non-point sources in the upstream of Qingshui River based on export coefficient models[J]. Science Technology and Engineering, 2020,20(33):13919-13927.
[19] 段扬,蒋洪强,吴文俊,等.基于改进输出系数模型的非点源污染负荷估算——以嫩江流域为例[J]. 环境保护科学, 2020,46(4):48-55. Duan Y, Jiang H Q, Wu W J, et al. Estimation of non-point source pollution load based on improved export coefficient model ——a case study of Nenjiang watershed[J]. Environmental Protection Science, 2020,46(4):48-55.
[20] 李政道,刘鸿雁,姜畅,等.基于输出系数模型的红枫湖保护区非点源污染负荷研究[J]. 水土保持通报, 2020,40(2):193-198,325. Li Z D, Liu H Y, Jiang C, et al. Non-point source pollution load of Hong Feng Lake reserve based on export coefficient model[J]. Bulletin of Soil ang Water Conservation, 2020,40(2):193-198.
[21] 胡富昶,敖天其,胡正,等.改进的输出系数模型在射洪县的非点源污染应用研究[J]. 中国农村水利水电, 2019,(6):78-82,92. Hu F C, Ao T Q, Hu Z, et al. Applied research on the improved export coefficient model in non－point source pollution in Shehong County[J]. China Rural Water and Hydropower, 2019,(6):78-82,92.
[22] 杨雯,敖天其,王文章,等.基于输出系数模型的琼江流域(安居段)农村非点源污染负荷评估[J]. 环境工程, 2018,36(10):140-144. Yang W, Ao T Q, Wang W Z, et al. Estimation of pollution loads from rural non-point sources in Qiongjiang River basin (Anju district) based on export coefficient modeling approach[J]. Environmental Engineering, 2018,36(10):140-144.
[23] 荆延德,张华美,孙笑笑.基于输出系数模型的南四湖流域非点源污染输出风险评估[J]. 水土保持通报, 2017,37(3):270-274,278. Jing Y D, Zhang H M, Sun X X. Risk assessment of non-point source pollution in Nansihu Lake basin using output coefficient model[J]. Bulletin of Soil ang Water Conservation, 2017,37(3):270-274,278.
[24] 张辰,陆建忠,陈晓玲.基于输出系数模型的云南洱海流域农业非点源污染研究[J]. 华中师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2017,51(1): 108-114. Zhang C, Lu J Z, Chen X L. Study of pollution from agricultural non-point sources in Lake Erhai watershed in Yunnan province based on export coefficient mode[J]. Journal of Central China Normal University (Natural Sciences), 2017,51(1):108-114.
[25] 李娜,韩维峥,沈梦楠,等.基于输出系数模型的水库汇水区农业面源污染负荷估算[J]. 农业工程学报, 2016,32(8):224-230. Li N, Han W Z, Shen M N, et al. Load evaluation of non-point source pollutants from reservoir based on export coefficient modeling[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, 2016,32(8):224-230.
[26] 邢宝秀,陈贺.北京市农业面源污染负荷及入河系数估算[J]. 中国水土保持, 2016,(5):34-37,77. Xing B X, Chen H. Estimation on agricultural non-point source pollution loads and inflow coefficient of Beijing[J]. Soil And Water Conservation in China, 2016,(5):34-37,77.
[27] 项颂,吴越,吕兴菊,等.洱海流域农业面源污染空间分布特征及分类控制策略[J]. 环境科学研究, 2020,33(11):2474-2483. Xiang S, Wu Y, Lv X J, et al. Characteristics and spatial distribution of agricultural non-point source pollution in Erhai Lake Basin and its classified control strategy[J]. Research of Environmental Sciences, 2020,33(11):2474-2483.
[28] 张正.伊通河流域非点源污染的模拟与预测[D]. 长春:吉林大学, 2014. Zhang Z. Simulation and prediction of non-point source pollution in Yitong river watershed[D]. Changchun: Jilin University, 2014.
[29] 姚婧,杨丽君,肖宇婷,等.基于社会-经济因子修正的沱江流域农业面源总磷污染负荷时空演变研究[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2022, 41(5):1022-1035. Yao J, Yang L J, Xiao Y T, et al. Spatial-temporal evolution of agricultural non-point sources of total phosphorus pollution loads in Tuojiang River watershed based on correction of social-economic factors[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science, 2022,41(5):1022-1035.
[30] 宋晓明,柳王荣,姜珊,等.湖南省农业面源污染与农村水环境质量的响应关系分析[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2022,41(7):1509-1519. Song X M, Liu W R, Jiang S, et al. Analysis on response relationship between agricultural non-point source pollution and rural water environmental quality in Hunan Province, China[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science, 2022,41(7):1509-1519.
[31] 胡晴,郭怀成,王雨琪,等.基于改进输出系数模型的农业源污染物负荷核算[J]. 北京大学学报((自然科学版), 2021,57(4):739-748. Hu Q, Guo H C, Wang Y Q, et al. Estimation of agricultural non-point source pollution loads based on improved export coefficient model[J]. Acta Scientiarum Naturalium Universitatis Pekinensis, 2021,57(4): 739-748.
[32] 唐肖阳,唐德善,鲁佳慧,等.汉江流域农业面源污染的源解析[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2018,37(10):2242-2251. Tang X Y, Tang D S, Lu J H, et al. Source apportionment of agricultural nonpoint source pollution in the Hanjiang River Basin[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science, 2018,37(10):2242-2251.
[33] Wang J, Wang D, Ni J, et al. Simulation of the dissolved nitrogen and phosphorus loads in different land uses in the Three Gorges Reservoir Region—based on the improved export coefficient model[J]. Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts, 2015,17(11):1976-1989.
[34] 寻乌县统计局.2020年寻乌县统计年鉴[M]. 赣州:寻乌县统计局, 2020年. Statistical yearbook in 2020 of Xunwu County[M]. Ganzhou: Xunwu County Bureau of Statistics, 2020.
[35] 宋红梅,李廷亮,刘洋,等.我国近20年主要粮食作物产量、进出口及化肥投入变化特征[J]. 水土保持学报, 2023,37(1):332-339. Song H M, Li T L, Liu Y, et al. Temporal variation of main grain crops yield, import and export and fertilizer consumption of CHINA in the past 20 years[J]. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 2023,37(1): 332-339.
[36] 寻乌县人民政府.《寻乌县"十四五"农业面源污染防治规划》(寻府发〔2022〕21号)[Z]. People's Government of Xun Wu County. The “14th Five-Year Plan” for the prevention and control of agricultural non-point source pollution in Xunwu County, (Xunfu〔2022〕No.21)[Z].
[37] Reddy N R, Sathe S K, Salunkhe D K. Phytates in legumes and cereals[J]. Advances in food research, 1982,28:1-92.
[38] 李雅楠,余利红,陈新美,等.来源于Penicillium sp. C1的水产用中性植酸酶基因在毕赤酵母中的表达及性质研究[J]. 生物技术通报, 2020,36(2):134-141. Li Y N, Yu L H, Chen X M, et al. Expression and characterization of Aquatic Neutral Phytase Gene from Penicillium sp. C1in Pichia pastoris[J]. Biotechnology Bulletin, 2020,36(2):134-141.
[39] 张晗,欧阳真程,赵小敏,等.江西省不同农田利用方式对土壤碳、氮和碳氮比的影响[J]. 环境科学学报, 2018,38(6):2486-2497. Zhang H, Ouyang Z C, Zhao X M, et al. Effects of different land use types on soil organic carbon,nitrogen and ratio of carbon to nitrogen in the plow layer of farmland soil in Jiangxi Province[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae, 2018,38(6):2486-2497.
[40] 李家科,彭凯,郝改瑞,等.黄河流域非点源污染负荷定量化与控制研究进展[J]. 水资源保护, 2021,37(1):90-102. Li J K, Peng K, Hao G R, et al. Research progress on quantification and control of non-point source pollution load in the Yellow River Basin[J]. Water Resources Protection, 2021,37(1):90-102.
[41] 刘安芳,阮蓉丹,李厅厅,等.猪舍内粪污废弃物和有害气体减量化工程技术研究[J]. 农业工程学报, 2019,35(15):200-210. Liu A F, Ruan R D, Li T T, et al. Research progress of in-house reduce engineering technology for piggery manure wastes and poisonous gas[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, 2019,35(15):200-210.
[42] 周海宾,丁京涛,孟海波,等.中国畜禽粪污资源化利用技术应用调研与发展分析[J]. 农业工程学报, 2022,38(9):237-246. Zhou H B, Ding J T, Meng H B, et al. Survey and development analysis of resource utilization technology of livestock and poultry wastes in China[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, 2022,38(9):237-246.
[43] 刘爱瑜,任二军,高玉红,等.冬季发酵床养羊的应用效果研究[J]. 家畜生态学报, 2022,43(5):73-77. Liu A Y, Ren E J, Gao Y H, et al. Analysis of fattening effect of raising sheep in fermentation bed in winter[J]. Acta Ecologiae Animalis Domastici, 2022,43(5):73-77.
[44] Liu R, Xu F, Zhang P, et al. Identifying non-point source critical source areas based on multi-factors at a basin scale with SWAT[J]. Journal of Hydrology, 2016,533:379-388.
[45] Yasarer L M W, Lohani S, Bingner R L, et al. Assessment of the soil vulnerability index and comparison with AnnAGNPS in two lower Mississippi River Basin watersheds[J]. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 2020,75(1):53-61.
[46] Zuo L, Gao J. Investigating the compounding effects of environmental factors on ecosystem services relationships for Ecological Conservation Red Line areas[J]. Land Degradation & Development, 2021,32(16):4609-4623.
[47] 陶园,徐静,任贺靖,等.黄河流域农业面源污染时空变化及因素分析[J]. 农业工程学报, 2021,37(4):257-264. Tao Y, Xu J, Ren H J, et al. Spatiotemporal evolution of agricultural non-point source pollution and its influencing factors in the Yellow River Basin[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, 2021,37(4):257-264.
[48] 丘丽清,吴根义,李想,等.基于等标污染负荷强度的海南省农村面源污染特征研究[J]. 农业资源与环境学报, 2023,40(1):55-63. Qiu L Q, Wu G Y, Li X, et al. Characteristics of agricultural non-point source pollution in Hainan rural area based on equal standard pollution load intensity[J]. Journal of Agricultural Resources and Environment, 2023,40(1):55-63.