考虑环境成本综合效益的泾河流域最佳管理措施评价与筛选

摘要
图/表
参考文献
相关文章 (15)

全文: PDF (1094 KB) HTML (0 KB)
输出: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)

摘要基于土壤和水评估工具（SWAT）评估9种单一最佳管理措施（BMPs）及其不同组合共计103种BMPs情景布设对非点源污染的消减效率，并基于信息熵的多属性决策方法评估泾河流域BMPs实施成本和非点源控制有效性之间的权衡.研究发现，SWAT模型在泾河流域非点源污染模拟中适用性较好，不同的BMPs对非点源污染负荷削减量存在较大差异，组合BMPs比单一BMPs在降低非点源污染负荷方面表现更好.在农业耕作过程中减少化肥50%的施用量、将坡度大于25°的农田退耕还草以及在河道进行植草水道措施建设是泾河流域具有最大环境成本综合效益值的优选组合BMPs.

	服务

	把本文推荐给朋友
	加入我的书架
	加入引用管理器
	E-mail Alert
	RSS
	作者相关文章
	阮炳南
	吴磊
	郭嘉薇
	杜佰林

关键词 ：非点源, 最佳管理措施, 环境成本综合效益, 泾河流域

Abstract：The Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) was used to evaluate the effectiveness of nine individual BMPs, as well as their various combinations-03 different scenarios in total-for reducing non-point source pollution (NPSP). A multi- attribute decision analysis method based on information entropy was also employed to assess the tradeoffs between the cost of implementing watershed BMPs and their effectiveness in controlling NPSP. The results reveals that the SWAT model was well-suited for simulating NPSP in the Jinghe River Basin, and the load reduction of NPSP varied greatly with different BMPs. Combined BMPs performed better than single BMPs in reducing the load of NPSP. The combination of reducing fertilizer application by 50% during agricultural cultivation, returning farmland with a slope greater than 25° to grassland, and planting grass in river channels was the preferred combined BMPs for the Jinghe River Basin with the highest comprehensive benefits value of environment and cost.

Key words： non-point source best management practices comprehensive benefits of environmental costs Jinghe River Basin

收稿日期: 2023-05-10

PACS:

X52

基金资助:国家自然科学基金项目（52070158；51679206）

通讯作者: 吴磊,教授,lwu@nwsuaf.edu.cn E-mail: lwu@nwsuaf.edu.cn

作者简介: 阮炳南(1999-),男,陕西咸阳人,西北农林科技大学硕士研究生,从事流域非点源污染控制研究.rbn@nwafu.edu.cn.

引用本文:

阮炳南, 吴磊, 郭嘉薇, 杜佰林. 考虑环境成本综合效益的泾河流域最佳管理措施评价与筛选[J]. 中国环境科学, 2024, 44(1): 319-328. RUAN Bing-nan, WU Lei, GUO Jia-wei, DU Bai-lin. Assessment and selection of the best management practices for the Jinghe River Basin considering the comprehensive benefits of environmental costs. CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCECE, 2024, 44(1): 319-328.

链接本文:

http://www.zghjkx.com.cn/CN/ 或 http://www.zghjkx.com.cn/CN/Y2024/V44/I1/319

[1]	Geng R, Yin P, Sharpley A N.A coupled model system to optimize the best management practices for nonpoint source pollution control [J].Journal of Cleaner Production, 2019,220:581-592.
[2]	Xu C, Hong J, Jia H, et al.Life cycle environmental and economic assessment of a LID-BMP treatment train system:A case study in China [J].Journal of Cleaner Production, 2017,149:227-237.
[3]	Uribe N, Srinivasan R, Corzo G, et al.Spatio-temporal critical source area patterns of runoff pollution from agricultural practices in the Colombian Andes [J].Ecological Engineering, 2020,149:105810.
[4]	Zuo D, Han Y, Gao X, et al.Identification of priority management areas for non-point source pollution based on critical source areas in an agricultural watershed of Northeast China [J].Environmental Research, 2022,214:113892.
[5]	Chen Y, Lu B, Xu C, et al.Uncertainty evaluation of best management practice effectiveness based on the AnnAGNPS Model [J].Water Resources Management, 2022,36(4):1307-1321.
[6]	López-Ballesteros A, Trolle D, Srinivasan R, et al.Assessing the effectiveness of potential best management practices for science-informed decision support at the watershed scale:The case of the Mar Menor coastal lagoon, Spain [J].Science of the Total Environment, 2023,859:160144.
[7]	Ricci G F, Jeong J, De Girolamo A M, et al.Effectiveness and feasibility of different management practices to reduce soil erosion in an agricultural watershed [J].Land Use Policy, 2020,90:104306.
[8]	Liu G, Chen L, Wang W, et al.A water quality management methodology for optimizing best management practices considering changes in long-term efficiency [J].Science of the Total Environment, 2020,725:138091.
[9]	Mukundan R, Hoang L, Gelda R K, et al.Climate change impact on nutrient loading in a water supply watershed [J].Journal of Hydrology, 2020,586:124868.
[10]	Jiang K, Li Z, Luo C, et al.The reduction effects of riparian reforestation on runoff and nutrient export based on AnnAGNPS model in a small typical watershed, China [J].Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2019,26(6):5934-5943.
[11]	Srinivas R, Drewitz M, Magner J.Evaluating watershed-based optimized decision support framework for conservation practice placement in Plum Creek Minnesota [J].Journal of Hydrology, 2020, 583:124573.
[12]	Fu X, Liu J, Mei C, et al.Effect of typhoon rainstorm patterns on the spatio-temporal distribution of non-point source pollution in a coastal urbanized watershed [J].Journal of Cleaner Production, 2021,292:126098.
[13]	Ricci G F, D'Ambrosio E, De Girolamo A M, et al.Efficiency and feasibility of best management practices to reduce nutrient loads in an agricultural river basin [J].Agricultural Water Management, 2022,259:107241.
[14]	Puertes C, Bautista I, Lidón A, et al.Best management practices scenario analysis to reduce agricultural nitrogen loads and sediment yield to the semiarid Mar Menor coastal lagoon (Spain) [J].Agricultural Systems, 2021,188:103029.
[15]	郭英壮,王晓燕,周丽丽,等.控制流域氮流失的最佳管理措施配置及效率评估[J].中国环境科学, 2021,41(2):860-871.Guo Y Z, Wang X Y, Zou L L, et al.Configuration and efficiency evaluation of the best management practices to control nitrogen loss in the watershed [J].China Environmental Science, 2021,41(2):860-871.
[16]	Mtibaa S, Hotta N, Irie M.Analysis of the efficacy and cost-effectiveness of best management practices for controlling sediment yield:A case study of the Joumine watershed, Tunisia [J].Science of the Total Environment, 2018,616-617:1-16.
[17]	Xin X, Yin W, Li K.Estimation of non-point source pollution loads with flux method in Danjiangkou Reservoir area, China [J].Water Science and Engineering, 2017,10(2):134-142.
[18]	Eckhardt K.How to construct recursive digital filters for baseflow separation [J].Hydrological Processes, 2005,19(2):507-515.
[19]	Lyne V, Hollick M.Stochastic time-variable rainfall-runoff modeling [C]//Institute of engineers Australia national conference.Barton, Australia:Institute of Engineers Australia, 1979,79(10):89-93.
[20]	黎坤,林凯荣,江涛,等.数字滤波法在点源和非点源污染负荷分割中的应用[J].环境科学研究, 2010,23(3):298-303.Li K, Lin K R, Jiang T, et al.Application of a digital filter in the differentiation of pollutant loads from point and non-point sources [J].Research of Environmental Sciences, 2010,23(3):298-303.
[21]	李撑娟,慕芳,段长林.渭北旱塬玉米施肥现状及对策——以咸阳市长武县为例[J].现代农业科技, 2016,45(20):35,39.Li C J, Mu F, Duan C L.Current situation and countermeasures of corn fertilization in Weibei Dry Plateau:taking Changwu County, Xianyang City as an example [J].Modern Agricultural Science and Technology, 2016,45(20):35,39.
[22]	赵护兵,王朝辉,高亚军,等.西北典型区域旱地冬小麦农户施肥调查分析[J].植物营养与肥料学报, 2013,19(4):840-848.Zhao H B, Wang Z H, Gao Y J, et al.Investigation and analysis of dryland winter wheat fertilizer application in northwest typical areas [J].Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizer, 2013,19(4):840-848.
[23]	张明,同延安,郭俊炜,等.陕西关中小麦/玉米轮作区氮肥用量及施氮现状评估[J].西北农林科技大学学报(自然科学版), 2011,39(4):152-158,164.Zhang M, Tong Y A, Guo J W, et al.Determination of reasonable nitrogen use and evaluation of application status in wheat/maize rotation system in Guanzhong area of Shaanxi Province [J].Journal of Northwest A&F University (Natural Science Edition), 2011,39(4):152-158,164.
[24]	常艳丽,刘俊梅,李玉会,等.陕西关中平原小麦/玉米轮作体系施肥现状调查与评价[J].西北农林科技大学学报(自然科学版), 2014, 42(8):51-61.Chang Y L, Liu J M, Li Y H, et al.Investigation and evaluation of fertilization under winter wheat and summer maize rotation system in Guanzhong Plain, Shaanxi Province [J].Journal of Northwest A & F University (Natural Science Edition), 2014,42(8):51-61.
[25]	财政部,国家发展改革委,国家林业局,等.关于扩大新一轮退耕还林还草规模的通知[EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2016-02/05/content_5039662.htm, 2015-12-31/2023-09-27.Ministry of Finance, National Development and Reform Commission, State Forestry Bureau, et al.Notice on expanding the scale of the new round of returning farmland to forests and grassland [EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2016-02/05/content_5039662.htm, 2015-12-31/2023-09-27.
[26]	Arabi M, Frankenberger J R, Engel B A, et al.Representation of agricultural conservation practices with SWAT [J].Hydrological Processes, 2008,22(16):3042-3055.
[27]	Tuppad P, Kannan N, Srinivasan R, et al.Simulation of agricultural management alternatives for watershed protection [J].Water Resources Management, 2010,24(12):3115-3144.
[28]	Arnold J G, Kiniri J R, Srinivasan R, et al.Soil and water assessment tool input/output file documentation.Version 2012[M].Texas Water Resource Institute, 2012.
[29]	Kaini P, Artita K, Nicklow J W.Optimizing structural best management practices using SWAT and genetic algorithm to improve water quality goals [J].Water Resources Management, 2012,26(7):1827-1845.
[30]	Liu Y, Wang R, Guo T, et al.Evaluating efficiencies and cost-effectiveness of best management practices in improving agricultural water quality using integrated SWAT and cost evaluation tool [J].Journal of Hydrology, 2019,577:123965.
[31]	吴之见.基于SWAT模型的流域面源污染最佳管理措施——贡江流域实例分析[D].南昌:南昌大学, 2022.Wu Z J.Best management practices of watershed non-point source pollution based on SWAT model-case analysis of Gongjiang Basin [D].Nanchang:Nanchang University, 2022.
[32]	张磊.基于SWAT模型珠溪河流域面源污染最佳管理措施研究[D].南昌:南昌大学, 2021.Zhang L.Research on non-point source pollution management measures of Zhuxi River Basin based on SWAT model [D].Nanchang:Nanchang University, 2021.
[33]	张玉娇.黄土旱塬麦玉轮作田长期保护性轮耕与施肥的培肥增产效应试验与模拟[D].杨凌:西北农林科技大学, 2018.Zhang Y J.Observation and simulation for soil fertility and crop yield effects of long-term rotational conservation tillage and fertilization on winter wheat-spring maize rotation field of Loess Plateau [D].Yangling:Northwest A & F University, 2018.
[34]	财政部,国家林业和草原局.关于印发《林业草原生态保护恢复资金管理办法》的通知[EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2020-05/06/content_5509081.htm, 2020-04-24/2023-09-27.Ministry of Finance, National Forestry and Grassland Administration.Notice on issuing the management measures for forest grassland ecological protection and restoration funds [EB/OL].https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2020-05/06/content_5509081.htm, 2020-04-24/2023-09-27.
[35]	黄康.基于SWAT模型的丹江流域面源污染最佳管理措施研究[D].西安:西安理工大学, 2020.Huang K.Research on non-point source pollution management measures of Danjiang River Basin based on SWAT model [D].Xi'an:Xi'an University of Technology, 2020.
[36]	王云凡.机械化秸秆还田技术的应用成本分析[J].江苏农机化, 2010,26(6):49-50.Wang Y F.Application cost analysis of mechanized straw returning technology [J].Jiangsu Agricultural Mechanization, 2010,26(6):49-50.
[37]	尹才.基于SWAT和信息熵的非点源污染最佳管理措施研究:以辽河上游为例[D].上海:华东师范大学, 2016.Study of best management practices of non-point source pollution based on SWAT and information entropy:a case of upstream of Liaohe River [D].Shanghai:East China Normal University, 2016.
[38]	Guan T, Xue B, Aa Y, et al.Contribution of nonpoint source pollution from baseflow of a typical agriculture-intensive basin in northern China [J].Environmental Research, 2022,212:113589.
[39]	郑宇,程香菊,王兆礼,等.韩江流域面源污染及与景观格局的关系[J].水资源保护, 2019,35(5):78-85.Zheng Y, Cheng X J, Wang, Z L, et al.Non-point source pollution in Hanjiang River Basin and its relation with landscape pattern [J].Water Resources Protection, 2019,35(5):78-85.
[40]	付婧,王云琦,马超,等.植被缓冲带对农业面源污染物的削减效益研究进展[J].水土保持学报, 2019,33(2):1-8.Fu J, Wang Y Q, Ma C, et al.Research progress on the effects of vegetation buffer zone on reducing agricultural non-point pollution [J].Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 2019,33(2):1-8.
[41]	Ng S L, Cai Q G, Ding S W, et al.Effects of contour hedgerows on water and soil conservation, crop productivity and nutrient budget for slope farmland in the Three Gorges Region (TGR) of China [J].Agroforestry Systems, 2008,74(3):279-291.
[42]	Liu R, Zhang P, Wang X, et al.Cost-effectiveness and cost-benefit analysis of BMPs in controlling agricultural nonpoint source pollution in China based on the SWAT model [J].Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2014,186(12):9011-9022.
[43]	Gashaw T, Dile Y T, Worqlul A W, et al.Evaluating the effectiveness of best management practices on soil erosion reduction using the SWAT model:for the case of Gumara watershed, Abbay (upper Blue Nile) basin [J].Environmental Management, 2021,68(2):240-261.
[44]	黄康,李怀恩,李家科,等.泾河流域农业非点源污染解析[J].人民黄河, 2021,43(6):106-111.Huang K, Li H E, Li J K, et al.Analysis of agricultural non-point source pollution in the Jinghe River Basin [J].YELLOW RIVER, 2021,43(6):106-111.
[45]	曾三云,龙君.基于信息熵的模糊多属性决策方法[J].广西科学, 2008,15(2):135-137.Zeng S Y, Long J.Fuzzy multi-attribute decision making method based on information entropy [J].Guangxi Sciences, 2008,15(2):135-137.
[46]	祖璇,毛军军,闫颖慧,等.基于信息熵的IITFN多属性决策方法[J].池州学院学报, 2015,29(3):24-26.Zu X, Mao J J, Yan Y H, et al.IITFN multi-attribute decision-making method based on information entropy [J].Journal of Chizhou University, 2015,29(3):24-26.
[47]	Sun T, Zhang H, Wang Y.The application of information entropy in basin level water waste permits allocation in China [J].Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2013,70:50-54.
[48]	郝改瑞,李家科,李怀恩,等.流域非点源污染模型及不确定分析方法研究进展[J].水力发电学报, 2018,37(12):54-64.Hao G R, Li J K, Li H E, et al.Advances in research of watershed non-point source pollution models and uncertainty analysis methods [J].Journal of Hydroelectric Engineering, 2018,37(12):54-64.
[49]	Abbaspour K C, Johnson C A, Van Genuchten M T.Estimating uncertain flow and transport parameters using a sequential uncertainty fitting procedure [J].Vadose Zone Journal, 2004,3(4):1340-1352.
[50]	Abbaspour K C, Yang J, Maximov I, et al.Modelling hydrology and water quality in the pre-alpine/alpine Thur watershed using SWAT [J].Journal of Hydrology, 2007,333(2):413-430.
[51]	Abbaspour K C, Rouholahnejad E, Vaghefi S, et al.A continental-scale hydrology and water quality model for Europe:Calibration and uncertainty of a high-resolution large-scale SWAT model [J].Journal of Hydrology, 2015,524:733-752.
[52]	Abbaspour K C.SWAT-CUP:SWAT calibration and uncertainty programs-A User Manual [M].Swiss Federal Institute Aquatic Science and Technology, 2015.