环境司法的多元主体环境责任协同效应

黎晓青; 李毅; 刘佳琦

PDF(583 KB)

中国环境科学 ›› 2024, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (8) : 4719-4730.

环境影响评价与管理

环境司法的多元主体环境责任协同效应

黎晓青¹, 李毅², 刘佳琦³

作者信息 +

Collaborative impact of environmental judiciary on the multi-entity environmental responsibility

LI Xiao-qing¹, LI Yi², LIU Jia-qi³

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

基于2008~2021年中级人民法院和检察院的环境诉讼数据,运用固定效应模型和中介效应模型,探究环境司法对多元主体环境责任协同的影响效应与作用机制,并进一步分析其异质性.研究发现:环境司法对多元主体环境责任协同具有显著促进作用;环境司法通过政府环境执法的“联动效应”、企业环境治理的“震慑效应”、公众环境关注的“引导效应”影响多元主体环境责任协同;进一步分析发现,当数智化水平越高、地区法治环境越好、以及在东部和中部地区时,环境司法对多元主体环境责任协同的促进效应更加明显.

Abstract

Utilizing the environmental litigation data gathered by the Intermediate People's Court and the Procuratorate spanning from 2008 to 2021, the study was conducted to examine the impact and underlying mechanism of environmental justice on the synergistic collaboration in fulfilling environmental responsibilities among multiple stakeholders. Through the application of the fixed effect model and the mediation effect model, the heterogeneity of this phenomenon was further scrutinized. It was observed that environmental justice played a pivotal role in fostering such collaboration, facilitated primarily by the “linkage effect” of governmental environmental law enforcement, the “deterrent effect” of corporate environmental governance, and the “guiding effect” of public environmental concern. A subsequent in-depth analysis indicated that this promotional effect of environmental justice on collaborative environmental responsibility was particularly pronounced in regions with higher levels of digitization, superior regional rule of law environments, and predominantly in the eastern and central regions.

导出引用

黎晓青, 李毅, 刘佳琦. 环境司法的多元主体环境责任协同效应[J]. 中国环境科学. 2024, 44(8): 4719-4730

LI Xiao-qing, LI Yi, LIU Jia-qi. Collaborative impact of environmental judiciary on the multi-entity environmental responsibility[J]. China Environmental Science. 2024, 44(8): 4719-4730

中图分类号： X322 F124.5

参考文献

[1] 胡宗义,何冰洋,李毅,等.异质性环境规制与企业环境责任履行[J]. 统计研究, 2022,39(12):22-37. Hu Z Y, He B Y, Li Y, et al. Heterogeneous environmental regulation tools and corporate environmental responsibility performance [J]. Statistical Research, 2022,39(12):22-37.
[2] 徐乐,王海霞,邵帅.长三角环境协同治理的非对称效应:基于多主体与多区域的双重视角[J]. 西安交通大学学报(社会科学版), 2023,43(2):128-142. Xu L, Wang H X, Shao S. The asymmetric effect of collaborative environmental governance of the Yangtze River Delta Region: Based on the dual perspectives of multi-agent and multi-region [J]. Journal of Xi'an Jiaotong University (Social Sciences), 2023,43(2):128-142.
[3] 张琦,邹梦琪.环境治理垂直改革的效果、基层机制与影响因素[J]. 经济研究, 2022,57(8):172-190. Zhang Q, Zou M Q. Real effect, grassroots mechanism and influencing factors of vertical management reform of environmental protection departments [J]. Economic Research Journal, 2022,57(8):172-190.
[4] Zeng H, Li X, Zhou Q, et al. Local government environmental regulatory pressures and corporate environmental strategies: Evidence from natural resource accountability audits in China [J]. Business Strategy and the Environment, 2022,31(7):3060-3082.
[5] Tu Z, Hu T, Shen R. Evaluating public participation impact on environmental protection and ecological efficiency in China: Evidence from PITI disclosure [J]. China Economic Review, 2019,55:111-123.
[6] Du J, Sun L. A benefit allocation model for the joint prevention and control of air pollution in China: In view of environmental justice [J]. Journal of Environmental Management, 2022,315:115132.
[7] 范子英,赵仁杰.法治强化能够促进污染治理吗?——来自环保法庭设立的证据[J]. 经济研究, 2019,54(3):21-37. Fan Z Y, Zhao R J. Does rule of law promote pollution control? Evidence from the establishment of the environmental courts [J]. Economic Research Journal, 2019,54(3):21-37.
[8] 李毅,胡宗义,周积琨,等.环境司法强化、邻近效应与区域污染治理[J]. 经济评论, 2022,(2):104-121. Li Y, Hu Z Y, Zhou J K, et al. Strengthening of environmental judicature, neighborhood effect and regional pollution abatement [J]. Economic Review, 2022,(2):104-121.
[9] Zhang Q, Yu Z, Kong D. The real effect of legal institutions: Environmental courts and firm environmental protection expenditure [J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 2019, 98:102254.
[10] 代昀昊,童心楚,王砾,等.法治强化能够促进企业绿色创新吗? [J]. 金融研究, 2023,(2):115-133. Dai Y H, Tong X C, Wang L, et al. Can legal enhancements promote green innovation? [J]. Journal of Financial Research, 2023,(2):115-133.
[11] Qi X, Wu Z, Xu J, Shan B. Environmental justice and green innovation: A quasi-natural experiment based on the establishment of environmental courts in China [J]. Ecological Economics, 2023,205: 107700.
[12] 孙慧,王慧,肖涵月,等.异质型责任主体的环境协同治理效果[J]. 资源科学, 2022,44(1):15-31. Sun H, Wang H, Xiao H Y, et al. Environmental collaborative governance effect of heterogeneous responsible subjects [J]. Resources Science, 2022,44(1):15-31.
[13] Chen X, Zhang J, Zeng H. Is corporate environmental responsibility synergistic with governmental environmental responsibility? Evidence from China [J]. Business Strategy and the Environment, 2020,29(8): 3669-3686.
[14] 姜渊,陈子琦.强化个体规制必然能减少污染总排放吗?——来自《环境保护法》的经验证据[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 2023, 33(2):19-29. Jiang Y, Chen Z Q. Does strengthening individual regulation necessarily reduce total pollution emissions? Empirical evidence from the Environmental Protection Law [J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2023,33(2):19-29.
[15] 薛艳华.论环境公益诉讼与环境行政执法之冲突与消解[J]. 中国软科学, 2020,(4):17-24. Xue Y H. On the conflict and dissolution of environmental public interest litigation and environmental administrative enforcement [J]. China Soft Science, 2020,(4):17-24.
[16] 孙岳兵.结构主义视角下法律功能范畴研究[J]. 求索, 2016, (1):28-31. Sun Y B. Research on Functional Categories of Law from the Perspective of Structuralism [J]. Seeker, 2016,(1):28-31.
[17] Camilla C, Luca P E. Health, environment and economic interests: From balancing to ensuring effective remedies [J]. Journal of European Tort Law, 2021,11(3):247-285.
[18] 刘伟,范文雨.公益诉讼提升了城市的环境治理绩效吗？——基于287个地级市微观数据的实证研究[J]. 上海财经大学学报, 2021,23(4):48-62. Liu W, Fan W Y. Does public interest litigation promote the performance of urban environmental governance? An empirical study based on micro-data of 287 prefecture-level cities [J]. Journal of Shanghai University of Finance and Economics, 2021,23(4):48-62.
[19] 翟华云,刘亚伟.环境司法专门化促进了企业环境治理吗?——来自专门环境法庭设置的准自然实验[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 2019,29(6):138-147. Zhai H Y, Liu Y W. Does environmental justice specialization promote corporate environmental governance? Quasi natural experiments from special environmental courts [J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2019,29(6):138-147.
[20] Oakes R A. Judicial resources and the public trust doctrine: A powerful tool of environmental protection? [J]. Transnational Environmental Law, 2018,7(3):469-489.
[21] Billiet M C, Blondiau T, Rousseau S. Punishing environmental crimes: An empirical study from lower courts to the court of appeal [J]. Regulation & Governance, 2014,8(4):472-496.
[22] Harrison J. Reflections on the role of international courts and tribunals in the settlement of environmental disputes and the development of international environmental law [J]. Journal of Environmental Law, 2013,25(3):501-514.
[23] Zhu X, Qiu T, Liu D. Resisting public monitoring in authoritarian regimes: Evidence from local environmental litigation in China [J]. Governance, 2023,36(2):459-477.
[24] Zhai T, Chang Y C. Standing of environmental public-interest litigants in China: Evolution, obstacles and solutions [J]. Journal of Environmental Law, 2018,30(3):369-397.
[25] 刘志仁,王嘉奇.黄河流域政府生态环境保护责任的立法规定与践行研究[J]. 中国软科学, 2022,(3):47-57. Liu Z R, Wang J Q. Study on the legislation and practice of government responsibility of ecological environmental protection in Yellow River Basin [J]. China Soft Science, 2022,(3):47-57.
[26] Hosta M, Zabkar V. Antecedents of environmentally and socially responsible sustainable consumer behavior [J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2021,171(2):273-293.
[27] 胡宗义,黎晓青,张煌文清,等.多元主体环境责任协同水平的地区差异与动态演进[J]. 湖南大学学报(社会科学版), 2022,36(4):77-84. Hu Z Y, Li X Q, Zhang H W Q, et al. Research on the evaluation of synergy degree of environmental responsibility of multiple subjects [J]. Journal of Hunan University (Social Sciences), 2022,36(4):77-84.
[28] 秦鹏,何建祥.检察环境行政公益诉讼受案范围的实证分析[J]. 浙江工商大学学报, 2018,(4):6-18. Qin P, He J X. Analysis of the scope of case acceptance of the environmental administrative public interest litigation brought by the procuratorate [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Gongshang University, 2018,(4):6-18.
[29] 孙晓华,郑辉,于润群,等.资源型城市转型升级:压力测算与方向选择[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 2020,30(4):54-62. Sun X H, Zheng H, Yu R Q, et al. The transformation and upgrading of resource-based cities: pressure measurement and direction selection [J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2020,30(4):54-62.
[30] 吴力波,杨眉敏,孙可哿.公众环境关注度对企业和政府环境治理的影响[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 2022,32(2):1-14. Wu L B, Yang M M, Sun K G. Impact of public environmental attention on environmental governance of enterprises and local governments [J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2022,32(2):1-14.
[31] 黄薇,杨杰.律师对民族地区司法资源配置的影响与贡献[J]. 西北民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2018,(5):128-136. Huang W, Yang J. The influence and contribution of lawyers to judicial resources allocation in ethnic areas [J]. Journal of Northwest Minzu University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), 2018,(5):128-136.
[32] 左卫民.迈向数字诉讼法:一种新趋势? [J]. 法律科学(西北政法大学学报), 2023,41(3):52-61. Zuo W M. Toward digital procedural law: A new trend? [J]. Science of Law (Journal of Northwest University of Political Science and Law), 2023,41(3):52-61.
[33] 黄国栋.比较法视野下智慧法院建设的中国经验、实践困境与路径优化[J]. 法律适用, 2023,492(3):129-138. Huang G D. Chinese experience, practical dilemmas, and perfection of the construction of smart court from the perspective of comparative law [J]. Journal of Law Application, 2023,492(3):129-138.
[34] 李鑫.智慧法院建设的理论基础与中国实践[J]. 政法论丛, 2021,204(5):128-138. Li X. Theoretical basis and Chinese practice of the construction of smart court [J]. Journal of Political Science and Law, 2021,204(5): 128-138.
[35] 潘越,谢玉湘,宁博,等.数智赋能、法治化营商环境建设与商业信用融资——来自“智慧法院”视角的经验证据[J]. 管理世界, 2022,38(9):194-208. Pan Y, Xie Y X, Ning B, et al. Data-intelligence empowerment, law- based business environment and trade credit financing: Evidence from “Smart Courts” [J]. Journal of Management World, 2022,38(9):194-208.
[36] 连玉君,彭方平,苏治.融资约束与流动性管理行为[J]. 金融研究, 2010,(10):158-171. Lian Y J, Peng F P, Su Z. Financing constraints and liquidity management [J]. Journal of Financial Research, 2010,(10):158-171.
[37] 方红星,张勇,王平.法制环境、供应链集中度与企业会计信息可比性[J]. 会计研究, 2017,(7):33-40. Fang H X, Zhang Y, Wang P. Legal environment, supply chain concentration and firm’s accounting information comparability [J]. Accounting Research, 2017,(7):33-40.
[38] 郑方辉,王正,魏红征.营商法治环境指数:评价体系与广东实证[J]. 广东社会科学, 2019,(5):214-223. Zheng F H, Wang Z, Wei H Z. The rule-of-law index of business environment: An evaluation system and a case study in Guangdong [J]. Social Sciences in Guangdong, 2019,(5):214-223.
[39] 马国洋,丁超帆.论城市经济发展对司法发展的影响——基于全国31个直辖市和省会城市的调查分析[J]. 城市发展研究, 2021,28(6):29-33. Ma G Y, Ding C F. On the influence of urban economic development on judicial development: Based on the investigation and analysis of 31municipalities and provincial cities in China [J]. Urban Development Studies, 2021,28(6):29-33.
[40] 孙笑侠,钟瑞庆.“先发”地区的先行法治化——以浙江省法治发展实践为例[J]. 学习与探索, 2010,(1):80-84. Sun X X, Zhong R Q. The advance rule of law in "first mover" regions: A case study of the development of rule of law in Zhejiang province [J]. Study & Exploration, 2010,(1):80-84.