滇东镉高背景区菜地土壤健康风险评价与基准

李洋; 张乃明; 魏复盛

PDF(513 KB)

中国环境科学 ›› 2020, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (10) : 4522-4530.

土壤污染与控制

滇东镉高背景区菜地土壤健康风险评价与基准

李洋^1,2, 张乃明¹, 魏复盛³

作者信息 +

A benchmark study on soil health risks of vegetable fields in a high-cadmium background area in eastern Yunnan

LI Yang^1,2, ZHANG Nai-ming¹, WEI Fu-sheng³

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

以滇东土壤-蔬菜系统为研究对象，通过土壤-蔬菜点位协同采样，分析了菜地土壤和不同蔬菜中Cd的积累特征及健康风险状况，并应用物种敏感度分布曲线（SSD）法，拟合出土壤Cd污染的健康风险值.结果表明：滇东菜地土壤中镉的累积量中有60.3%的样点超过了污染筛选值，曲靖市的土壤Cd质量分数平均值较高；不同类别蔬菜吸收富集镉的能力不同，叶菜类和根茎类蔬菜对Cd有较强的吸收富集能力，超标率也相对较高，研究区采集到的23种蔬菜中出现镉超标的蔬菜有11种，但蔬菜总的超标率为18%；健康风险评价结果显示无论是对成人还是儿童均不存在非致癌健康风险，3类蔬菜的风险大小依次为叶菜类 > 根茎类 > 茄果（辣椒）类，研究区蔬菜中Cd对成人和儿童均不存在健康风险，儿童的Cd暴露风险高于成人；滇东蔬菜健康风险基准值是基于保护95%及5%的蔬菜品种安全所得的土壤风险值，种植根茎类蔬菜时，HC₅=0.35mg/kg、HC₉₅=2.8mg/kg；种植辣椒类蔬菜时，HC₅=0.15mg/kg、HC₉₅=8.7mg/kg；种植叶菜类蔬菜时，HC₅=0.36mg/kg、HC₉₅=13.8mg/kg.

Abstract

This paper studied accumulation characteristics and health risk status of cadmium (Cd) in the soil and different vegetables in soil-vegetable systems in east Yunnan, China, a high Cd background area, with samples collected through the point-to-point collaborative sampling method. The cadmium health risk benchmark of vegetable soil was also derived with species sensitivity distribution curve (SSD) method. There were 60.3% of the sampling sites for the cadmium accumulation in the soil of vegetable fields exceeded the soil screening value, and higher average values of soil Cd mass fraction were found in Qujing prefecture. The adsorption and accumulation abilities of Cd were found to vary by types of vegetables. Leafy vegetables and rhizome vegetables had strong abilities to absorb and enrich Cd, and the percentage of exceeding standards was relatively high. Among 23kinds of vegetables collected in the study area, there were 11kinds of vegetables which exceeded the Cd standard, the total percentage of vegetable samples exceeding the standard was 18%. The health risk assessment showed that there were no non-cancer risk for both the adults and children, the risk levels for three vegetables were leafy vegetables > rhizomes > solanaceous fruits. Cd in the vegetables had no health risk for adults and children in the study area, although the exposure risk for children was higher than that for adults; Based on the principle of protecting 95% and 5% vegetable varieties, the vegetable health risk criteria were developed for various vegetables. When planting root vegetables, HC₅=0.35mg/kg, HC₉₅=2.8mg/kg; When planting pepper vegetables, HC₅=0.15mg/kg, HC₉₅=8.7mg/kg; when planting leafy vegetables, HC₅=0.36mg/kg, HC₉₅=13.8mg/kg.

导出引用

李洋, 张乃明, 魏复盛. 滇东镉高背景区菜地土壤健康风险评价与基准[J]. 中国环境科学. 2020, 40(10): 4522-4530

LI Yang, ZHANG Nai-ming, WEI Fu-sheng. A benchmark study on soil health risks of vegetable fields in a high-cadmium background area in eastern Yunnan[J]. China Environmental Science. 2020, 40(10): 4522-4530

中图分类号： X820.4

参考文献

[1] Fowler B A. Monitoring of human populations for early markers of cadmium toxicity:A review[J]. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology, 2009,238(3):294-300.
[2] Shiyu Wang, Wenyong Wu, Fei Liu, et al. Accumulation of heavy metals in soil-crop systems:A review for wheat and corn[J]. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2017,24(18):15209-15225.
[3] Laura Poggio, Borut Vrscaj, Erwin Hepperle, et al. Introducing a method of human health risk evaluation for planning and soil quality management of heavy metal polluted soils[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2008,88:64-72.
[4] 陈能场,郑煜基,何晓峰,等.《全国土壤污染状况调查公报》探析[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2017,36(9):1689-1692. Chen N C,Zheng Y J, He X F, Li X F, et al. Analysis of the "National Bulletin on Soil Pollution Survey"[J]. Journal of Agricultural Environmental Sciences, 2017,36(9):1689-1692.
[5] 中国环境监测总站.中国土壤元素背景值[M]. 北京:中国环境科学出版社, 1990:253-256. China Environmental Monitoring Station. Chinese soil element background values[M]. Beijing:China Environmental Science Press, 1990:253-256.
[6] 李丽辉,王宝禄.云南省土壤As、Cd元素地球化学特征[J]. 物探与化探, 2008,32(5):497-501. Li L H, Wang B L. The Geochemical Characteristics of As､Cd Elements in Soil in Yunnan Province[J]. Geophysical and Geochemical Exploration, 2008,32(5):497-501.
[7] 王宇,彭淑惠,杨双兰.云南岩溶区As､Cd元素异常特征[J]. 中国岩溶, 2012,31(4):377-381. Wang Y, Peng S H, Yang S L. Anomalous characteristics of As､Cd elements in karst area of Yunnan[J]. Chinese Karst, 2012,31(4):377-381.
[8] GB15618-2018土壤环境质量农用地土壤污染风险管控标准(试行)[S]. 北京:中国标准出版社, 2018. GB15618-2018 Soil Environmental Quality Standards for Soil Pollution Risk Control of Agricultural Land (Trial)[S]. Beijing:China Standard Press, 2018.
[9] 邹晓锦,仇荣亮,周小勇,等.大宝山矿区重金属污染对人体健康风险的研究[J]. 环境科学学报, 2008,(7):1406-1412. Zou X J, Qiu R L, Zhou X Y, et al. Research on human health risks of heavy metal pollution in Dabaoshan mining area[J]. Journal of Environmental Science, 2008,(7):1406-1412.
[10] 侯艳伟,池海峰,毕丽君.生物炭施用对矿区污染农田土壤上油菜生长和重金属富集的影响[J]. 生态环境学报, 2014,23(6):1057-1063. Hou Y W, Chi H F, Bi L J. Effects of biochar application on rape growth and heavy metal enrichment on contaminated farmland soil in mining area[J]. Journal of Eco-Environment, 2014,23(6):1057-1063.
[11] 邵金秋,刘楚琛,阎秀兰,等.河北省典型污灌区农田镉污染特征及环境风险评价[J]. 环境科学学报, 2019,39(3):917-927. Shao J Q, Liu C C, Yan X L, et al. Cadmium pollution characteristics and environmental risk assessment of farmland in typical sewage irrigation areas of Hebei Province[J]. Journal of Environmental Sciences, 2019,39(3):917-927.
[12] GB2762-2017食品安全国家标准食品中污染物限量[S]. 北京:中国标准出版社, 2017. GB2762-2017 National Food Safety Standards Limits of Contaminants in Food[S]. Beijing:China Standard Press, 2017.
[13] 关于发布《食品安全国家标准食品中镉的测定》(GB5009.15-2014)等13项食品安全国家标准的公告[J]. 中国食品卫生杂志, 2015, 27(3):321. Announcement on the release of 13national food safety standards including "National Food Safety Standards-Determination of Cadmium in Foods" (GB5009.15-2014)[J]. Chinese Journal of Food Hygiene, 2015,27(3):321.
[14] 彭礼洪,孟范平,刘群群,等.东营市北部海域文蛤重金属污染特征与食用风险评价[J]. 中国环境科学, 2020,40(4):1800-1808. Peng L H, Meng F P, Liu Q Q, et al. Characteristics of heavy metal pollution and food risk assessment of Clams in the northern waters of Dongying City[J]. Chinese Environmental Science, 2020,40(4):1800-1808.
[15] 李晓燕,陈同斌,谭勇壁,等.北京市小麦籽粒的重金属含量及其健康风险分析[J]. 地理研究, 2008,27(6):1340-1346. Li X Y, Chen T B, Tan Y B, et al. Heavy metal content and health risk analysis of wheat grains in Beijing[J]. Geographical Research, 2008, 27(6):1340-1346.
[16] Bennett D, Kastenberg W E, Mckone T E. A multimedia, multiple pathway risk assessment of atrazine:The impact of age differentiated exposure including joint uncertainty and variability[J]. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 1999,63(2):185-198.
[17] 陈波宇,郑斯瑞,牛希成,等.物种敏感度分布及其在生态毒理学中的应用[J]. 生态毒理学报, 2010,5(4):491-497. Chen B Y, Zheng S R, Niu X C, et al. Species sensitivity distribution and its application in ecotoxicology[J]. Journal of Ecotoxicology, 2010,5(4):491-497.
[18] 孙聪,陈世宝,宋文恩,等.不同品种水稻对土壤中镉的富集特征及敏感性分布(SSD)[J]. 中国农业科学, 2014,47(12):2384-2394. Sun C, Chen S B, Song W E, et al. Enrichment characteristics and sensitivity distribution (SSD) of different rice varieties to soil cadmium[J]. Chinese Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 2014,47(12):2384-2394.
[19] Wei He, Kong Xiangzhen Kong, Ning Qin, et al. Combining species sensitivity distribution (SSD) model and thermodynamic index (exergy) for system-level ecological risk assessment of contaminates in aquatic ecosystems.[J]. Environment international, 2019,133:105275.
[20] Ding C, Zhang T, Li X, et al. Major controlling factors and prediction models for mercury transfer from soil to carrot[J]. Journal of Soils and Sediments, 2014,14(6):1136-1146.
[21] Michael Fryer, Chris D. Collins, Helen Ferrier, et al. Human exposure modelling for chemical risk assessment:a review of current approaches and research and policy implications[J]. Environmental Science and Policy, 2006,9(3):261-274.
[22] 褚卓栋,刘文菊,肖亚兵,等.中草药种植区土壤及草药中重金属含量状况及评价[J]. 环境科学, 2010,31(6):1600-1607. Chu Z D, Liu W J, Xiao Y B, et al. Status and evaluation of heavy metal content in soil and herbs in Chinese herbal medicine planting areas[J]. Environmental Science, 2010,31(6):1600-1607.
[23] 刘洪莲,李艳慧,李恋卿,等.太湖地区某地农田土壤及农产品中重金属污染及风险评价[J]. 安全与环境学报, 2006,6(5):60-63. Liu H L, Li Y H, Li L Q, et al. Heavy Metal Pollution and Risk Assessment of Farmland Soil and Agricultural Products in a Taihu Region[J]. Journal of Safety and Environment, 2006,6(5):60-63.
[24] 赵秀峰,王强盛,石宁宁,等.石化园区周边农田土壤重金属污染分析与评价[J]. 环境科学学报, 2010,30(1):133-141. Zhao X F, Wang Q S, Shi N N, et al. Analysis and Evaluation of Heavy Metal Pollution of Farmland Soil Around Petrochemical Park[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae, 2010,30(1):133-141.
[25] 刘庆,孙景宽,陈印平,等.不同采样尺度下土壤重金属的空间变异特征[J]. 土壤通报, 2009,40(6):1406-1410. Liu Q, Sun J K, Chen Y P, et al. Spatial variability of soil heavy metals at different sampling scales[J]. Soil Bulletin, 2009, 40(6):1406-1410.
[26] 任艳军,任学军,马为民,等.14种叶菜类蔬菜对土壤中重金属吸收累积差异的分析与评价[J]. 河北科技师范学院学报, 2019,33(3):23-34. Ren Y J, Ren X J, Ma W M, et al. Analysis and evaluation of the accumulation difference of heavy metal absorption in soil by 14leafy vegetables[J]. Journal of Hebei Normal University of Science and Technology, 2019,33(3):23-34.
[27] 陈同斌,郑袁明,陈煌,等.北京市不同土地利用类型的土壤砷含量特征[J]. 地理研究, 2005,(2):229-235. Chen T B, Zheng Y M, Chen H, et al. Characteristics of soil arsenic content in different land use types in Beijing[J]. Geographical Research, 2005,(2):229-235.
[28] 邹素敏,杜瑞英,文典,等.不同品种蔬菜重金属污染评价和富集特征研究[J]. 生态环境学报, 2017,26(4):714-720. Zou S, Du R Y, Wen D, et al. Evaluation of heavy metal pollution and enrichment characteristics of different vegetable varieties[J]. Journal of Eco-Environment, 2017,26(4):714-720.
[29] 张子杨,郭瞻宇,管伟豆,等.硫磺和放线菌强化植物修复土壤镉污染[J]. 中国环境科学, 2019,39(5):2106-2114. Zhang Z Y, Guo Z Y, Guan W D, et al. Sulfur and actinomycetes strengthen plants to remediate soil cadmium pollution[J]. Chinese Environmental Science, 2019,39(5):2106-2114.
[30] 王丽,张丽娟,易皓,等.中国南方某钨矿污染区叶菜类蔬菜中重金属含量分布状况及健康风险评价[J]. 中国农村水利水电, 2015, (3):71-75. Wang L, Zhang L J, Yi H, et al. Distribution and health risk assessment of heavy metal content in leafy vegetables in a tungsten mine contaminated area in southern China[J]. China Rural Water and Hydropower, 2015,(3):71-75.
[31] 任艳军,马建军.秦皇岛市蔬菜中重金属污染状况及健康风险分析[J]. 安全与环境学报, 2013,13(2):79-84. Ren Y J, Ma J J. Heavy metal pollution in vegetables and health risk analysis in Qinhuangdao City[J]. Journal of Safety and Environment, 2013,13(2):79-84.
[32] 孙清斌,尹春芹,邓金锋,等.大冶矿区土壤-蔬菜重金属污染特征及健康风险评价[J]. 环境化学, 2013,32(4):671-677. Sun Q B, Yin C Q, Deng J F, et al. Soil-vegetable heavy metal pollution characteristics and health risk assessment in Daye mining area[J]. Environmental Chemistry, 2013,32(4):671-677.
[33] 周亚龙,郭志娟,王成文,等.云南省镇雄县土壤重金属污染及潜在生态风险评估[J]. 物探与化探, 2019,43(6):1358-1366. Zhou Y L, Guo Z J, Wang C W, et al. Heavy metal pollution and potential ecological risk assessment of soil in Zhenxiong County, Yunnan Province[J]. Geophysical and Geochemical Exploration, 2019,43(6):1358-1366.
[34] 窦韦强,安毅,秦莉,等.农用地土壤重金属生态安全阈值确定方法的研究进展[J]. 生态毒理学报, 2019,14(4):54-64. Dou W Q, An Y, Qin L, et al. Research progress on the determination method of ecological safety threshold of heavy metals in agricultural land soil[J]. Journal of Ecotoxicology, 2019,14(4):54-64.
[35] 贾劼,解静芳,范仁俊,等.酸雨和降尘污染对菠菜和生菜几种重金属含量的影响[J]. 华北农学报, 2008,23(4):213-216. Jia J, Xie J F, Fan R J, et al. Effects of acid rain and dust pollution on the contents of several heavy metals in spinach and lettuce[J]. Journal of North China Agriculture, 2008,23(4):213-216.
[36] 周开胜.蚌埠及周边地区土壤和蔬菜的重金属污染研究[J]. 环境与职业医学, 2018,35(10):910-916. Zhou K S. Research on heavy metal pollution of soil and vegetables in Bengbu and surrounding areas[J]. Environment and Occupational Medicine, 2018,35(10):910-916.
[37] 史明易,王祖伟,王嘉宝,等.基于富集系数对蔬菜地土壤重金属的安全阈值研究[J]. 干旱区资源与环境, 2020,34(2):130-134. Shi M Y, Wang Z W, Wang J B, et al. Study on the safety threshold of heavy metals in vegetable fields based on enrichment coefficient[J]. Arid Area Resources and Environment, 2020,34(2):130-134.