双酚S和双酚F诱导斑马鱼的神经发育毒性及联合作用分析

杨潇; 包志伟; 韩晓雯; 苏心聪; 孟令浩; 代卓雅; 王泽君; 王慧利

PDF(3595 KB)

中国环境科学 ›› 2025, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (2) : 1088-1098.

环境毒理与健康

双酚S和双酚F诱导斑马鱼的神经发育毒性及联合作用分析

杨潇, 包志伟, 韩晓雯, 苏心聪, 孟令浩, 代卓雅, 王泽君, 王慧利

作者信息 +

Neurodevelopmental toxicity and combined effects of bisphenol S and bisphenol F induced zebrafish

YANG Xiao, BAO Zhi-wei, HAN Xiao-wen, SU Xin-cong, MENG Ling-hao, DAI Zhuo-ya, WANG Ze-jun, WANG Hui-li

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

本研究选择亚致死剂量下等效应的BPS和BPF,从斑马鱼的发育表型、运动行为、血管发育和神经毒性等4个方面比较神经发育毒性的差异和联合毒性研究.结果表明,虽然LC5的BPS和BPF均会诱导斑马鱼表观畸形,如抑制了斑马鱼游泳囊、卵黄囊等发育;BPS和BPF的暴露会影响斑马鱼的早期运动行为,这与心血管系统损伤以及神经中枢系统损伤有着潜在的关联.BPS和BPF造成了斑马鱼心血管发育的异常,尾静脉(CV)宽度缩短;DA、AChE以及NO神经递质的异常传递导致了斑马鱼神经元发育受损,这对侧线神经系统的功能产生了直接的影响,进而导致斑马鱼早期运动行为的受损. BPF暴露更容易诱导斑马鱼的组织、器官毒性,而BPS直接毒性影响要小于BPF,更多的通过分子层次表现出来,这表明两者作用模式具有一定程度的差异性.此外,结合浓度加和模型的联合作用分析来分析20个检测指标,BPS和BPF产生加和作用有16个,达到了80%,因此混合物产生的毒性效应应当引起重视.研究结果为BPS、BPF及其混合物暴露后的健康风险评估与风险预警给予相关的参考依据.

Abstract

In this research, BPS and BPF with sublethal dose were selected to compare the difference and combined toxicity of neurodevelopmental toxicity in zebrafish from four aspects: developmental phenotype, motor behavior, vascular development and neurotoxicity. The results showed that both BPS and BPF of LC5 induced apparent deformities in zebrafish, such as inhibiting the development of swimming sac and yolk sac. Exposure to BPS and BPF can affect the early motor behavior of zebrafish, which is potentially associated with damage to the cardiovascular system and nervous central system. BPS and BPF caused abnormal cardiovascular development and shortened caudal vein (CV) width in zebrafish. The abnormal transmission of DA, AChE and NO neurotransmitters leads to the impaired development of zebrafish neurons, which has a direct impact on the function of the lateral nervous system, and then leads to the impaired early motor behavior of zebrafish. BPS and BPF show different toxicity differences in specific indicators. BPF exposure is more likely to induce tissue and organ toxicity in zebrafish, while the direct toxicity of BPS is less than that of BPF, which is more manifested at the molecular level, indicating that there is a certain degree of difference in the mode of action of the two. In addition, combined with the analysis of the combined action of concentration addition model, the addition action between BPS and BPF is mainly. The results of this study provide a reference for health risk assessment and risk warning after exposure to BPS, BPF and their mixtures.

导出引用

杨潇, 包志伟, 韩晓雯, 苏心聪, 孟令浩, 代卓雅, 王泽君, 王慧利. 双酚S和双酚F诱导斑马鱼的神经发育毒性及联合作用分析[J]. 中国环境科学. 2025, 45(2): 1088-1098

YANG Xiao, BAO Zhi-wei, HAN Xiao-wen, SU Xin-cong, MENG Ling-hao, DAI Zhuo-ya, WANG Ze-jun, WANG Hui-li. Neurodevelopmental toxicity and combined effects of bisphenol S and bisphenol F induced zebrafish[J]. China Environmental Science. 2025, 45(2): 1088-1098

中图分类号： X503

参考文献

[1] Björnsdotter M K, de Boer J, Ballesteros-Gómez A. Bisphenol A and replacements in thermal paper: A review [J]. Chemosphere, 2017,182: 691-706.
[2] Han Y, Liu Y, Rong X, et al. Exposure, distribution, and ecological risk of four new bisphenol analogs in the typical lake region of Taihu Lake [J]. Exposure and Health, 2024,16(4):1027-1037.
[3] 李晓蒙,张立实,隋海霞,等.双酚S和双酚F的危害识别 [J]. 卫生研究, 2018,47(6):1018-1021.Li X M, Zhang L S, Sui H X, et al. Hazard identification of bisphenol S and bisphenol F [J]. Health Research, 2018,47(6):1018-1021.
[4] Tišler T, Krel A, Gerželj U, et al. Hazard identification and risk characterization of bisphenols A, F and AF to aquatic organisms [J]. Environmental pollution, 2016,212:472-479.
[5] 李红梅,熊忆茗,徐海明,等.双酚A类似物的雄性生殖毒性研究进展 [J]. 中国环境科学, 2021,41(6):2939-2945.Li H M, Xiong Y M, Xu H M, et al. Research progress on male reproductive toxicity of bisphenol A analogues [J]. China Environmental Science, 2021,41(6):2939-2945.
[6] Hao L, Ru S, Qin J, et al. Transgenerational effects of parental bisphenol S exposure on zebrafish (Danio rerio) reproduction [J]. Food Chemical Toxicology, 2022,165:113142.
[7] Salahinejad A, Attaran A, Meuthen D, et al. Maternal exposure to bisphenol S induces neuropeptide signaling dysfunction and oxidative stress in the brain, and abnormal social behaviors in zebrafish (Danio rerio) offspring [J]. Science of The Total Environment, 2022,830: 154794.
[8] Mu X, Liu J, Wang H, et al. Bisphenol F impaired zebrafish cognitive ability through inducing neural cell heterogeneous responses [J]. Environmental Science Technology, 2022,56(12):8528-8540.
[9] Gu J, Li L, Yin X, et al. Long-term exposure of zebrafish to bisphenol F: Adverse effects on parental reproduction and offspring neurodevelopment [J]. Aquatic Toxicology, 2022,248:106190.
[10] Liu J, Shen J, Lu G, et al. Multilevel ecotoxicity assessment of environmentally relevant bisphenol F concentrations in Daphnia magna [J]. Chemosphere, 2020,240:124917.
[11] Escrivá L, Zilliacus J, Hessel E, et al. Assessment of the endocrine disrupting properties of bisphenol AF: A case study applying the European regulatory criteria and guidance [J]. Environmental Health, 2021,20(1):48.
[12] Meador J P. The fish early-life stage sublethal toxicity syndrome-A high-dose baseline toxicity response [J]. Environmental Pollution, 2021,291:118201.
[13] 沈杰,刘建超,陆光华,等.双酚S和双酚F在水环境中的分布,毒理效应及其生态风险研究进展 [J]. 生态毒理学报, 2018,13(5):37-48.Shen J, Liu J C, Lu G H, et al. Distribution, toxicological effects and ecological risks of bisphenol S and bisphenol F in water environment [J]. Journal of Ecotoxicology, 2018,13(5):37-48.
[14] Darvishi M, Safari R, Hoseinifar S H, et al. Sublethal doses of diazinon affected reproductive, immune, and oxidative status in female zebrafish (Danio rerio) [J]. Aquaculture Reports, 2022,22:100944.
[15] Huang P, Liu S-S, Wang Z-J, et al. Study on the characterization of pesticide modes of action similarity and the multi-endpoint combined toxicity of pesticide mixtures to Caenorhabditis elegans [J]. Science of The Total Environment, 2023,893:164918.
[16] 杨倩,刘建梅,丁洁,等.双酚F对斑马鱼早期生命阶段内分泌干扰效应研究 [J]. Asian Journals of Ecotoxicology, 2021,16(3):1673-1.Yang Q, Liu J M, Ding J, et al. Effects of bisphenol F on endocrine disruptors in early life stages of zebrafish [J]. Asian Journals of Ecotoxicology, 2021,16(3):1673.
[17] Ni A, Fang L, Xi M, et al. Neurotoxic effects of 2-ethylhexyl diphenyl phosphate exposure on zebrafish larvae: Insight into inflammation-driven changes in early motor behavior [J]. Science of The Total Environment, 2024,915:170131.
[18] Wang H, Meng Z, Zhou L, et al. Effects of acetochlor on neurogenesis and behaviour in zebrafish at early developmental stages [J]. Chemosphere, 2019,220:954-964.
[19] Liu W, Pan Y, Yang L, et al. Developmental toxicity of TCBPA on the nervous and cardiovascular systems of zebrafish (Danio rerio): A combination of transcriptomic and metabolomics [J]. Journal of Environmental Sciences, 2023,127:197-209.
[20] Sun M, Ding R, Ma Y, et al. Cardiovascular toxicity assessment of polyethylene nanoplastics on developing zebrafish embryos [J]. Chemosphere, 2021,282:131124.
[21] Hardy K, Amariutei A E, De Faveri F, et al. Functional development and regeneration of hair cells in the zebrafish lateral line [J]. The Journal of physiology, 2021,599(16):3913-3936.
[22] Lu Y L, Liu Y, McCoy M J, et al. MiR-124 synergism with ELAVL3enhances target gene expression to promote neuronal maturity [J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2021, 118(22):e2015454118.
[23] 韩晓雯,徐婕妤,王伟伟,等.三氯生和双酚A对斑马鱼神经毒性的比较研究 [J]. 中国环境科学, 2024,44(2):1111-1121.Han X W, Xu J Y, Wang W W, et al. Comparative study on the neurotoxicity of triclosan and bisphenol A in zebrafish [J]. China Environmental Science, 2024,44(2):1111-1121.
[24] Yuan L, Qian L, Qian Y, et al. Bisphenol F-induced neurotoxicity toward zebrafish embryos [J]. Environmental Science Technology, 2019,53(24):14638-14648.
[25] Gu J, Zhang J, Chen Y, et al. Neurobehavioral effects of bisphenol S exposure in early life stages of zebrafish larvae (Danio rerio) [J]. Chemosphere, 2019,217:629-635.
[26] Kim Y, Kim S S, Park B H, et al. Mechanism of bisphenol F affecting motor system and motor activity in zebrafish [J]. Toxics, 2023,11(6): 477.
[27] Gu J, Wu J, Xu S, et al. Bisphenol F exposure impairs neurodevelopment in zebrafish larvae (Danio rerio) [J]. Ecotoxicology Environmental Safety, 2020,188:109870.
[28] 任文娟,汪贞,杨先海,等.双酚A及其类似物对斑马鱼成鱼及胚胎的急性毒性 [J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2017,33(4):372-378.Ren W J, Wang Z, Yang X H, et al. Acute toxicity of bisphenol A and its analogues to zebrafish adults and embryos [J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2017,33(4):372-378.
[29] Gu J, Guo M, Yin X, et al. A systematic comparison of neurotoxicity of bisphenol A and its derivatives in zebrafish [J]. Science of the Total Environment, 2022,805:150210.
[30] Kim Y, Kim S S, Park B H, et al. Mechanism of bisphenol F affecting motor system and motor activity in zebrafish [J]. Toxics, 2023, 11(6):477.
[31] Zhang J, Wang W, Li P, et al. Bisphenol S induces cardiovascular toxicity by disturbing the development of the common cardinal vein and myocardial contractility in zebrafish embryos [J]. Aquatic Toxicology, 2022,251:106294.
[32] Ji G, Gu J, Guo M, et al. A systematic comparison of the developmental vascular toxicity of bisphenol A and its alternatives in vivo and in vitro [J]. Chemosphere, 2022,291:132936.
[33] 王倩倩,王永花,汪贝贝,等.双酚F和双酚S联合暴露下的斑马鱼富集及神经毒性 [J]. 中国环境科学, 2020,40(2):865-873.Wang Q Q, Wang Y H, Wang B B, et al. Enrichment and neurotoxicity of bisphenol F and bisphenol S combined exposure in zebrafish [J]. China Environmental Science, 2020,40(2):865-873.
[34] Nematollahi D, Baniardalan M, Khazalpour S, et al. Product diversity by changing the electrode potential. Synthesis, kinetic evaluation and antibacterial activity of arylsulfonyl-4, 4'-biphenol and bis-arylsulfonyl-4, 4'-biphenol derivatives [J]. Electrochimica Acta, 2016, 191:98-105.
[35] Liao S, Wu H, He X, et al. Promoting effect of methyne/methylene moiety of bisphenol E/F on phthalonitrile resin curing: Expanding the structural design route of phthalonitrile resin [J]. Polymer, 2020,210: 123001.
[36] Ying S, Linyan Z, Zhongli C, et al. Evidence of increased estrogenicity upon metabolism of Bisphenol F -Elucidation of the key metabolites [J]. Science of The Total Environment, 2021,787:147669.
[37] Bokkers B G, Slob W J C R i T. Deriving a data-based interspecies assessment factor using the NOAEL and the benchmark dose approach [J]. Critical Reviews in Toxicology, 2007,37(5):355-373.
[38] Wang Z-J, Zheng Q-F, Liu S-S, et al. New methods of top-to-down mixture toxicity prediction: A case study of eliminating of the effects of cosolvent from binary mixtures [J]. Chemosphere, 2022,289: 133190.
[39] Ukić Š, Sigurnjak M, Cvetnić M, et al. Toxicity of pharmaceuticals in binary mixtures: Assessment by additive and non-additive toxicity models [J]. Ecotoxicology Environmental safety, 2019,185:109696.
[40] 徐小庆,郭璞,王晓静,等.浓度加和模型与独立作用模型在化学混合物联合毒性预测方面的研究进展 [J]. 动物医学进展, 2020,41(4): 91-94.Xu X Q, Guo P, Wang X J, et al. Research progress of concentration addition model and independent action model in predicting combined toxicity of chemical mixtures [J]. Advances in Veterinary Medicine, 2020,41(4):91-94.