A review on the progresses in medium clogging and its control during groundwater artificial recharge
YE xue-yan1,2, SUN qiu-jie1, DU xin-qiang1,2, ZHAO jing-tong1, LU ying1,2, CUI rui-juan1
1. College of New Energy and Environment, Jilin University, Changchun 130021, China; 2. Key Laboratory of Groundwater Resources and Environment, Ministry of Education, Jilin University, Changchun 130021, China
Abstract：Artificial recharge has been widely utilized as an effective method for solving groundwater over-extraction and its adverse environmental impacts. However, the clogging issue during artificial recharge is one of the factorslimiting its application; because the clogging affects the infiltration rate, running cost and engineering longevity of recharge facilities. We have reviewed to summarize the current state of artificial recharge types, clogging mechanisms, clogging prediction and approaches for clogging prevention and control. This review suggests that the medium clogging is basically dependent on medium attributes, physical and chemical characteristics of water source and hydrogeochemical conditions. And clogging prediction methods include water quality index, empirical formula and mathematical model; while clogging prevention is mainly based on water quality control, and clogging treatment requires a combination of physical and chemical methods. Current approaches for artificial recharge are increasingly well-developed, but the infiltration promotion technologies of artificial recharge based on the spatial differences in infiltration media and the complexity of water source conditions need further investigation.
冶雪艳, 孙邱杰, 杜新强, 赵婧彤, 路莹, 崔瑞娟. 地下水人工补给过程介质堵塞及控制研究进展[J]. 中国环境科学, 2022, 42(9): 4145-4156.
YE xue-yan, SUN qiu-jie, DU xin-qiang, ZHAO jing-tong, LU ying, CUI rui-juan. A review on the progresses in medium clogging and its control during groundwater artificial recharge. CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCECE, 2022, 42(9): 4145-4156.
王建华,陆垂裕.华北地区地下水超采综合治理技术支撑体系探析 [J]. 中国水利, 2020,(13):19-21,25. Wang J H, Lu C Y. Studies on technical support system for comprehensive control of groundwater overexploitation in North China [J]. China Water Resources, 2020,(13):19-21,25.
[2]
中华人民共和国水利部:走近地下水 [Z]. http://szy.mwr.gov.cn/cskp/201910/t20191024_1365927.html, 2019 Ministry of Water Resources, PRC: Approaching groundwater [Z]. http://szy.mwr.gov.cn/cskp/201910/t20191024_1365927.html, 2019.
[3]
陈家琦.全球变化和水资源的可持续开发 [J]. 水科学进展, 1996, (3):4-9. Chen J Q. Global change and sustainable development of water resources [J]. Advances in Water Science, 1996,(3):4-9.
[4]
翟远征,姜 亚,夏雪莲,等.永定河生态补水下渗对地下水质量的影响 [J]. 中国环境科学, 2022,42(4):1861-1868. Zhai Y Z, Jiang Y, Xia X L, et al. Impact of infiltration of ecology water replenishment of the Yongding River on groundwater quality and the mechanism [J]. China Environmental Science, 2022,42(4): 1861-1868.
[5]
Cui X C, Chen C L, Sun S, et al. Acceleration of saturated porous media clogging and silicon dissolution due to low concentrations of Al(III) in the recharge of reclaimed water [J]. Water Research, 2018, 143(0):136-145.
[6]
Dillon P, Stuyfzand P, Grischek T, et al. Sixty years of global progress in managed aquifer recharge [J]. Hydrogeology Journal, 2019,27(1): 1-30.
[7]
Du X Q, Ye X Y, Zhang X W. Clogging of saturated porous media by silt-sized suspended solids under varying physical conditions during managed aquifer recharge [J]. Hydrological Processes, 2018,32(14): 2254-2262.
[8]
Pyne R D G. Aquifer storage recovery: A guide to groundwater recharge through wells [M]. Utrecht, The Netherlands: ASR Press 2nd edn, 2005.
[9]
王维平, Dillon P, Vanderzalm J.中国-澳大利亚含水层补给管理新进展 [M]. 郑州:黄河水利出版社, 2009. Wang W P, Dillon P, Vanderzalm J. Recent advance in China-Australia manage aquifer recharge [M]. Zhengzhou: Yellow River Water Conservancy Press, 2009.
[10]
李旺林,束龙仓,殷宗泽.地下水库的概念和设计理论 [J]. 水利学报, 2006,(5):613-618. Li W L, Shu L C, Yin Z Z. Concept and design theory of groundwater reservoir [J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2006,(5):613-618.
[11]
杜新强,廖资生,李砚阁,等.地下水库调蓄水资源的研究现状与展望 [J]. 科技进步与对策, 2005,22(2):178-180. Du X Q, Liao Z S, Li Y G et al. Study on the distribution and storage of water resources by groundwater reservoir [J]. Science & Technology Progress and Policy, 2005,22(2):178-180.
[12]
Page D, Vanderzalm J, Miotlinski K, et al. Determining treatment requirements for turbid river water to avoid clogging of aquifer storage and recovery wells in siliceous alluvium [J]. Water Research, 2014,66: 99-110.
[13]
杜新强,冶雪艳,路 莹,等.地下水人工回灌堵塞问题研究进展 [J]. 地球科学进展, 2009,24(9):973-980. Du X Q, Ye X Y, Lu Y, et al. Advances in clogging research of artificial recharge[J]. Advances in Earth Science, 2009,24(9):973-980.
[14]
Bloetscher F, Sham C H, Danko J J, et al. Status of aquifer storage and recovery in the United States–2013 [J]. British Journal of Science, 2015,12(2):70-88.
[15]
Bloetscher F, Sham C H, Danko J J, et al. Lessons learned from aquifer storage and recovery (ASR) systems in the United States [J]. Journal of Water Resource and Protection, 2014,6(17):1603-1629.
[16]
Bloetscher F, Sham C H, Ratick S J. Aquifer storage and recovery: Can an updated inventory predict future system success? [J]. American Water Works Association. Journal, 2020,112(10):48-55.
[17]
武晓峰,唐 杰.地下水人工回灌与再利用 [J]. 工程勘察, 1998,(4): 39-41,44. Wu X F. Tang J. Artificial recharge and reuse of groundwater [J]. Geotechnical Investigation & Surveying, 1998,(4):39-41,44.
[18]
孙 颖,苗礼文.北京市深井人工回灌现状调查与前景分析 [J]. 水文地质工程地质, 2001,(1):21-23,48. Sun Y, Miao L W,Current situation investigation and prospect analysis of artificaial recharge of ground water in Beijing city [J]. Hydrogeology & Engineering Geology, 2001,(1):21-23,48.
[19]
Martin R. Clogging issues associated with managed aquifer recharge methods [R]. IAH Commission on Managing Aquifer Recharge. Australia, 2013.
[20]
Dillon P, Pavelic P, Page D, et al. Managed aquifer recharge: an introduction [R]. Waterlines Report Series No.13, February 2009, National Water Commisssion, Australia, 2009.
[21]
张人权,梁 杏,靳孟贵,等.水文地质学基础(第六版) [M]. 北京:地质出版社, 2011.01 Zhang R Q, Liang X, Jin M G, et al. Fundamentals of hydrogeology (6th edition) [M]. Beijing: Geology Press, 2011.01.
[22]
房佩贤,卫中鼎,廖资生,等.专门水文地质学 [M]. 北京:地质出版社, 1996,11. Fang P X, Wei Z D, Liao Z S. Special hydrogeology [M]. Beijing: Geology Press, 1996.11.
[23]
Gale I, Dillon P. Strategies for managed aquifer recharge (MAR) in semi-arid areas [R]. Paris: International Hydrological Programme (IHP), 2005.
[24]
Valverde J P B, Stefan C, Nava A P, et al. Inventory of managed aquifer recharge schemes in Latin America and the Caribbean [J]. Sustainable Water Resources Management, 2018,4(2):163–178.
[25]
赵婧彤.地下水人工补给过程中的促渗技术研究 [D]. 长春:吉林大学, 2021. Zhao J T. Study on Infiltration Promotion Techniques during Artificial Recharge of Groundwater [D]. Changchun: Jilin University, 2021.
[26]
Jimenez B, Chávez A. Quality assessment of an aquifer recharged with wastewater for its potential use as drinking source: “El Mezquital Valley”case [J]. Water Science Technology, 2004,50(2):269–276.
[27]
Dahlke H E, Brown A G, Orloff S, et al. Managed winter flooding of alfalfa recharges groundwater with minimal crop damage [J]. California Agriculture. 2018,72(1):65–75.
[28]
Drewes J E, Reinhard M, Fox P. Comparing microfiltration-reverse osmosis and soil-aquifer treatment for indirect potable reuse of water [J]. Water Research, 2003,37(15):3612-3621.
[29]
Zhang H, Xu Y X, Kanyerere T. A review of the managed aquifer recharge: Historical development, current situation and perspectives [J]. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth., 2020,118:102887.
[30]
Casanova J, Devau N, Pettenati M. Managed aquifer recharge: an overview of issues and options [J]. Integrated groundwater management, 2016:413-434.
[31]
Herman B. Artificial recharge of groundwater: hydrogeology and engineering [J]. Hydrogeology Journal, 2002,10(1):121–142.
[32]
Sprenger C, Hartog N, Hernández M,et al. Inventory of managed aquifer recharge sites in Europe: historical development, current situation and perspectives [J]. Hydrogeology Journal, 2017,25(6): 1909–1922.
[33]
Boisson A, Baïsset M, Alazard M, et al. Comparison of surface and groundwater balance approaches in the evaluation of managed aquifer recharge structures: case of a percolation tank in a crystalline aquifer in India [J]. Journal of Hydrology, 2014.519(part B):1620–1633.
[34]
Kim R H, Lee S, Lee J H, et al. Design of rainwater management system for Eco-Housing complex [J]. Rainwater and Urban Design, 2007,2007:634-639.
[35]
杜新强,贾思达,方 敏,等.海绵城市建设对区域地下水资源的补给效应 [J]. 水资源保护, 2019,35(2):13-17,24. Du X Q, Jia S D, Fang M, et al. Recharge effect of sponge city construction on regional groundwater resources [J]. Water Resources Protection, 2019,35(2):13-17,24.
[36]
黄金林,迟宝明,路 莹,等.地下储水空间雨洪资源调蓄技术的研究进展 [J]. 灌溉排水学报, 2008,(2):123-127. Huang J L, Chi B M, Lu Y, et al. Advances on rain-flood regulation and storage technology by groundwater storage space [J]. Journal of Irrigation and Drainage, 2008,(2):123-127.
[37]
Dillon P. Future management of aquifer recharge [J]. Hydrogeology Journal, 2005,13(1):313-316.
[38]
杜新强,路 莹,冶雪艳,等.地下水人工回灌过程中介质堵塞与水质变化研究进展 [J]. 黑龙江大学工程学报, 2018,9(2):1-6,103. Du X Q, Lu Y, Ye X Y, et al. Advances on porous medium clogging and water quality change during artificial recharge of groundwater [J]. Journal of Engineering of Heilongjiang University, 2018,9(2):1-6,103.
[39]
Ren J H, Packman A I, Rehg K J. Effects of suspended sediment characteristics and bed sediment transport on streambed clogging [J]. Hydrological Processes, 2005,19(2):413-427.
[40]
Vigneswaran S, Suazo R B. A detailed investigation of physical and biological clogging during artificial recharge [J]. Water, Air, and Soil Pollut, 1987,35(1):119-140.
[41]
王子佳.城市雨洪水地下回灌过程中悬浮物堵塞规律的实验研究 [D]. 长春:吉林大学, 2012. Wang Z J. Laboratory research on the law of suspended solids clogging during urban stormwater groundwater recharge [D]. Changchun: Jilin University, 2012.
[42]
路 莹,杜新强,迟宝明,等.地下水人工回灌过程中多孔介质悬浮物堵塞实验 [J]. 吉林大学学报(地球科学版), 2011,41(2):448-454. Lu Y, Du X Q, Chi B M et al. The porous media clogging due to suspended solid during the artificial recharge of groundwater [J]. Journal of Jilin University, 2011,41(2):448-454.
[43]
赵婧彤,冶雪艳,杜新强,等.不同浓度悬浮物颗粒在多孔介质中迁移特性研究 [J]. 水利水电技术, 2019,50(10):25-31. Zhao J T, Du X Q, Ye X Y, et al. Study on the migration characteristics of suspended particles inporous media during different concentration of suspension [J]. Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering, 2019,50(10):25-31.
[44]
Brankica M D, Andelka P, Milan D. The effect of iron oxidation in the groundwater of the alluvial aquifer of the Velika Morava River, Serbia, on the clogging of water supply wells [J]. Journal of the Serbian Chemical Society, 2015,80(7):947-957.
[45]
Oberdorfer J A, Peterson F L. Waste-water injection: geochemical and biogeochemical clogging processes [J]. Groundwater, 1985,23(6): 753–761.
[46]
Thullner M. Comparison of bioclogging effects in saturated porous media within one- and two-dimensional flow systems [J]. Ecological Engineering. 2010,36(2):176-196.
[47]
Xia L, Zheng X L, Shao H B, et al. Influences of environmental factors on bacterial extracellular polymeric substances production in porous media [J]. Journal of Hydrology, 2014,519(Part D):3153-3162.
[48]
Roche K R, Drummond J D, Boano F, et al. Benthic biofilm controls on fine particle dynamics in streams [J]. Water Resources Research, 2017,53(1):222-236.
[49]
夏 璐,郑西来,段玉环,等.砂柱微生物堵塞过程及机理分析 [J]. 水利学报, 2014,45(6):749-755. Xia L, Zheng X L, Duan Y H, et al. Analysis of process and mechanism of bioclogging in aqueous media [J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2014,45(6):749-755.
[50]
Holocher J, Peeters F, Aeschbach-Hertig W, et al. Kinetic model of gas bubble dissolution in groundwater and its implications for the dissolved gas composition [J]. Environmental Science and Technology, 2003,37(7):1337–1343.
[51]
Heilweil V M, Solomon D K, Ortiz G. Silt and gas accumulation beneath an artificial recharge spreading basin, Southwestern Utah, U.S.A [J]. Boletin Geologicoy Minero, 2009,120(2):185–196.
[52]
束龙仓,张永杰,许 杨,等.地下水人工回灌气相堵塞特征的试验研究 [J]. 水科学进展, 2017,28(5):756-762. Shu L C, Zhang Y J, Xu Y, et al. Experimental studies on gas-clogging characteristics during groundwater artificial recharge [J]. Advances in Water Science, 2017,28(5):756-762.
[53]
Heilweil V M, Solomon D K, Perkins K S, et al. Gas-partitioning tracer test to quantify trapped gas during recharge [J]. Groundwater. 2004,42(4):589–600.
[54]
Schippers JC, Verdouw J. The modified fouling index, a method of determining the fouling characteristics of water [J]. Desalination, 1980,32:137-148.
[55]
Sultana S, Ahmed K M. Assessing risk of clogging in community scale managed aquifer recharge sites for drinking water in the coastal plain of south-west Bangladesh [J]. Bangladesh Journal of Scientific Research, 2014,27(1):75-86.
[56]
Hijnen W A M, Van der Koou D. The effect of low concentrations of assimilable organic carbon (AOC) in water on biological clogging of sand beds [J]. Water Research, 1992,26(7):963-972.
[57]
van der Kooij D, Vrouwenvelder H S, Veenendaal H R. Kinetic aspects of biofilm formation on surfaces exposed to drinking water [J]. Water Science and Technology, 1995,32(8):61-65.
[58]
Thomas R L. Coarse filter media for artificial recharge [S]//.Report of Investigation; no. 60, Illinois State Water Survey, 1968.
[59]
Olsthoorn T N. The clogging of recharge wells, main subjects [C]//KIWA-communications 72.Working Group on Recharge Wells, 1982:136.
[60]
黄大英.淤堵对人工回灌效果影响的试验研究 [J]. 北京水利科技, 1993,(1):24-32. Huang D Y. Experimental study on the effect of blockage on artificial recharge [J]. Beijing Water Resources Technology, 1993,(1):24-32.
[61]
Robert L S, William C B. Wastewater-induced soil clogging development [J]. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 1987,113(3): 550-566.
[62]
Osei-Bonsu K. Clogging by sediments in injected fluid flowing radially in a confined aquifer [D]. Flinders University of South Australia, 1997.
[63]
Omura T, Umita T, Nenov V, et al. Biological oxidation of ferrous iron in high acid mine drainage by fluidized bed reactor [J]. Water Science & Technology, 1991,23(7-9):1447-1456.
[64]
Okubo T, Matsumoto J. Effect of infiltration rate on biological clogging and water quality changes during artificial recharge [J]. Water Resources Research, 1979,15(6):1536-1542.
[65]
Molz F J, Widdowson M A, Benefield L D. Simulation of microbial growth dynamics coupled to nutrient and oxygen transport in porous media [J]. Water Resources Research, 1986,22(8):1207-1216.
[66]
路 莹,杜新强,范 伟,等.地下水人工回灌过程中微生物堵塞的预测 [J]. 湖南大学学报(自然科学版), 2012,39(1):77-80. Lu Y, Du X Q, Fan W, et al. Prediction of microbial clogging in groundwater artificial recharge [J]. Journal of Hunan University, 2012,39(1):77-80.
[67]
Taylor S W, Jaffé P R. Biofilm growth and the related changes in the physical properties of a porous medium: 3. Dispersivity and model verification [J]. Water Resources Research, 1990,26(9):2171-2180.
[68]
冶雪艳,李 铮,罗 冉,等.地下水人工补给过程中流速对多孔介质胶体堵塞的影响机理 [J]. 化工学报, 2021,72(11):5520-5532. Ye X Y, Li Z, Luo R, et al.Mechanism of influence of flow velocity on colloid blockage in porous mediaduring artificial groundwater recharge [J]. CIESC Journal, 2021,72(11):5520-5532.
[69]
Lu Y, Du X Q, Yang Y S, et al. Compatibility assessment of recharge water with native groundwater using reactive hydrogeochemical modeling in Pinggu, Beijing [J]. CLEAN – Soil, Air, Water, 2014, 42(6):722-730.
[70]
Alfredo P P. Integrated modeling of clogging processes in artificial groundwater recharge [D]. Technical University of Catalonia, 2001.
[71]
王子佳.基于风险评价的北京平谷盆地雨洪水回灌水质标准研究[D]. 长春:吉林大学, 2009. Wang Z J. Study on Water Quality Standards for Storm Water Infiltration Based on Risk Assessment in Pinggu Basin of Beijing [D]. Changchun: Jilin University, 2009.
[72]
Ferná E E. Practical management to minimize the effects of clogging in managed aquifer recharge wells at two sites in the Guadiana Basin, Spain [J]. Journal of Hydrologic Engineering, 2014,20(3):1.
[73]
Mohammed Z, Nasre-Dine A, Abdellah A, et al. Assessment of clogging of managed aquifer recharge in a semi-arid region [J]. Science of the Total Environment, 2020,730:139107.
[74]
白芝兰,赵乐军.高效强化常规水处理技术综述 [C]//2008年全国给水排水技术交流会暨全国水网理事会换届大会论文集.中国四川成都, 2008. Bai Z L, Zhao L J. Review on efficient enhancement of conventional water treatment technology [C]//Proceedings of 2008National Water Supply and Drainage Technology Exchange Conference and National Water Network Council Meeting. Chengdu, Sichuan, China, 2008.
[75]
郝晓地,仇付国,张璐平,等.应用数学模拟技术升级改造二级污水处理工艺 [J]. 中国给水排水, 2007,(16):25-29. Hao X D, Qiu F G, Zhang L P, et al. Upgrading of secondary wastewater treatment process by using mathematical simulation technology [J]. China Water & Wastewater, 2007,(16):25-29.
[76]
白晓慧,贺兰喜,王宝贞.常规饮用水净化技术面临的挑战及对策 [J]. 水科学进展, 2002,(1):122-127. Bai X H, He L X, Wang B Z. Conventional drinking water treatment technologies:existing problems and countermeasures [J]. Advances in Water Science, 2002,(1):122-127.
[77]
Jeong H Y, Jun S C, Cheon J Y, et al. A review on clogging mechanisms and managements in aquifer storage and recovery (ASR) applications [J]. Geosciences Journal, 2018,22(4):667-679.
[78]
王占生,刘文君.我国给水深度处理应用状况与发展趋势 [J]. 中国给水排水, 2005,(9):29-33. Wang Z S, Liu W J. Application of advanced treatment of drinking water and its perspective [J]. China Water & Wastewater, 2005,(9):29- 33.
[79]
J·鲁比奥,崔洪山,李长根.作为废水处理技术中的浮选法 [J]. 国外金属矿选矿, 2002,(6):4-13. Rubio J, Cui H S, Li C G. As the flotation method in wastewater treatment technology [J]. Metallic Ore Dressing Abroad, 2002,(6): 4-13.
[80]
Al-Faqheri W, Thio T H G, Qasaimeh M A, et al. Particle/cell separation on microfluidic platforms based on centrifugation effect: a review [J]. Microfluidics and Nanofluidics, 2017,21(6):102.
[81]
Yeap S P, Lim J K, Ooi B S, et al. Agglomeration, colloidal stability, and magnetic separation of magnetic nanoparticles: collective influences on environmental engineering applications [J]. Journal of Nanoparticle Research, 2017,19(11):1-15.
[82]
Liu Z, Yan M F, Gao Y H, et al. Research progress of electrostatic water treatment technology [J]. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 2021,831:012028.
[83]
汪 艳.曝气吹脱技术去除水源水氯苯的初步研究 [D]. 哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学, 2011. Wang Y. Preliminary research on aeration and stripping technology to remove chlorobenzene in source wate [D]. Harbin: Harbin Institute of Technology, 2011.
[84]
刘洪涛,徐冠华,朱果逸.先进水处理技术研究进展 [J]. 水处理技术, 2008,(4):1-7,30. Liu H T, Xu G H, Zhu G Y. Progress of research on advanced water treatment technology [J]. Technology of Water Treatment, 2008,(4): 1-7,30.
[85]
Jie Y, Michele I V D, Peter M H. Selection and evaluation of water pretreatment technologies for managed aquifer recharge (MAR) with reclaimed wate [J]. Chemosphere, 2019,(236):124886.
[86]
Lin X C, Shamsaei E, Kong B, et al. Porous diffusion dialysis membranes for rapid acid recovery [J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2016,502:76-83.
[87]
刘欣颖,肖慧杰.几种中水处理技术简介 [J]. 内蒙古石油化工, 2010, 36(3):98-99. Liu X Y, Xiao H J. Brief of intermediate water treatment technologies [J]. Inner Mongulia Petrochemical Industry, 2010,36(3):98-99.
[88]
Deed M E R; Preene M. Managing the clogging of groundwater wells [C]//16th European Conference on Soil Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering (ECSMGE), Edinburgh, United kingdom, 2015.
[89]
路 莹.北京平谷地区雨洪水地下回灌堵塞机理分析与模拟研究 [D]. 长春:吉林大学, 2009. Lu Y. Mechanism and modeling of clogging during groundwater recharge with stormwater in Pinggu of Beijing [D]. Changchun: Jilin University, 2009.
[90]
Driscoll F G. Groundwater and Wells (2nd edition) [M]. St. Paul: Johnson Screens, 1986.
[91]
张永发,祝济之,胡长华.超声波地层解堵机理研究初步 [J]. 北京理工大学学报, 2006,(5):397-400. Zhang Y F, Zhu J Z, Hu C H. Preliminary study on the mechanism of removal of bridge formation by ultrasonic waves [J]. Journal of Beijing Institute of Technology, 2006,(5):397-400.
[92]
GB/T 14848-2017 地下水质量标准 [S]. GB/T 14848-2017 Quality standard for ground water [S].
[93]
Richard D H B, Nebo J, Sumaya I, et al. Four decades of water recycling in Atlantis (Western Cape, South Africa):Past, present and future [J]. Water SA. 2016,42(4):577-594.
[94]
Pyne R D G. Groundwater recharge and wells: A guide to aquifer storage recovery [M]. Boca Raton: Lewis Publishers, CRC Press, 1995.
[95]
Stuyfzand P J, Osma J. Clogging issues with aquifer storage and recovery of reclaimed water in the Brackish Werribee Aquifer, Melbourne, Australia [J]. Water, 2019,11(9):1807.
[96]
Wang Z K, Shu L C, Su X R, et al. Evaluating particle deposition in the artificial groundwater recharge process by physical and CT imaging experiments [J]. Water Resources Management, 2021,35(14): 4789-4807.
