裂隙介质VOCs赋存迁移特征与场地修复难点

王刘炜; 杨小东; 侯德义

PDF(679 KB)

中国环境科学 ›› 2022, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (10) : 4780-4789.

环境生态

裂隙介质VOCs赋存迁移特征与场地修复难点

王刘炜, 杨小东, 侯德义

作者信息 +

VOCs in fractured aquifers: presence, migration characteristics, and difficulties for contaminated site remediation

WANG Liu-wei, YANG Xiao-dong, HOU De-yi

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

梳理了裂隙介质污染的研究方法，分析裂隙介质中VOCs的赋存迁移特征与修复技术原理，结合我国实际情形分析该类场地修复治理的难点并提出相关建议.裂隙介质场地中，对流弥散、吸附解吸、跨界输移的协同作用影响VOCs的环境行为与归趋.在理论层面，基于分离、化学氧化与生物转化过程的修复原理能够实现裂隙中VOCs的去除，但由于氧化还原产物堵塞、吸附态污染物反向扩散等原因，裂隙介质VOCs污染修复过程可能存在拖尾、修复后可能存在反弹的问题.与孔隙介质场地相比，不确定性是造成裂隙介质场地修复困难的主要原因，主要体现在场地调查阶段样品代表性差、修复治理过程中裂隙对污染物的阻滞作用所致传质受限、污染物易发生跨介质迁移风险等方面.后续研究亟需在充分认识裂隙污染物迁移转化机制的基础上，进一步探索适合我国修复与再利用实际情形的修复和风险管控模式.

Abstract

This review summarizes experimental methods in this field, assesses migration characteristics of VOCs in fractures, and analyzes mechanisms involved in the remediation of fractured aquifers. Furthermore, implications for contaminated site remediation are proposed. Advection-dispersion, adsorption-desorption and cross-media migration affect the fate of VOCs in fractured aquifers. Both crack clogging by chemical oxidation products and back diffusion of trapped VOCs affect the remediation efficiency, leading to tailing and rebounding of the remedy project in fractured aquifers. Low representativeness of environmental samples, limited mass transfer rate of reagents and substrates, and cross-media transport are the major obstacles hindering fractured aquifer remediation, where future works must spare no effort to overcome.

导出引用

王刘炜, 杨小东, 侯德义. 裂隙介质VOCs赋存迁移特征与场地修复难点[J]. 中国环境科学. 2022, 42(10): 4780-4789

WANG Liu-wei, YANG Xiao-dong, HOU De-yi. VOCs in fractured aquifers: presence, migration characteristics, and difficulties for contaminated site remediation[J]. China Environmental Science. 2022, 42(10): 4780-4789

中图分类号： X523

参考文献

[1] 陈梦舫.我国工业污染场地土壤与地下水重金属修复技术综述[J].中国科学院院刊, 2014,29(3):327-335.Chen M F.Review on heavy metal remediation technology of soil and groundwater at industrially contaminated site in China[J].Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2014,29(3):327-335.
[2] 戚圣琦,侯德义,王轶冬,等.VOCs相间非平衡态迁移对土壤修复效果的影响[J].环境科学研究, 2021,34(6):1464-1472.Qi S Q, Hou D Y, Wang Y D, et al.The influence of VOCs nonequilibrium transport on soil remediation[J].Research of Environmental Sciences, 2021,34(6):1464-1472.
[3] Qi S, Wang Y, Wang L, et al.Impact of atmospheric pressure fluctuations on nonequilibrium transport of volatile organic contaminants in the vadose zone:experimental and numerical modeling[J].Water Resources Research, 2021,57(8):e2020WR029344.
[4] 王金生,刘嘉蔚,韩科学,等.甲苯在毛细带中的垂向迁移过程及其环境要素响应[J].中国环境科学, 2022,42(1):68-75.Wang J S, Liu J W, Han K X, et al.The vertical migration process of toluene in capillary zone and its response to environmental factors[J].China Environmental Science, 2022,42(1):68-75.
[5] 李广贺,刘兆昌,张旭.水资源利用工程与管理[M].北京:清华大学出版社, 1998:142-146.Li G H, Liu Z C, Zhang X.Use and management of water resources[M].Beijing:Tsinghua University Press, 1998:142-146.
[6] 杨硕,赵雯楚,阎秀兰,等.Pickering乳化强化地下水三氯乙烯NAPL修复[J].中国环境科学, 2022,42(8):3713-3719.Yang S, Zhao W C, Yan X L, et al.Pickering emulsion for enhancing oxidative degradation of trichloroethylene nonaqueous-phase liquid in groundwater[J].China Environmental Science, 2022,42(8):3713-3719.
[7] 王颖,汪洋,唐军,等.基于TMVOC的水位波动带土壤气相抽提模拟[J].中国环境科学, 2020,40(1):350-356.Wang Y, Wang Y, Tang J, et al.Numerical simulation of SVE in groundwater table fluctuation zone based on TMVOC[J].China Environmental Science, 2020,40(1):350-356.
[8] Hartmann A, Jasechko S, Gleeson T, et al.Risk of groundwater contamination widely underestimated because of fast flow into aquifers[J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2021,118(20):e2024492118.
[9] Council N R.Conceptual models of flow and transport in the fractured vadose zone[M].Washington, D.C., USA:National Academies Press, 2001.
[10] 生态环境部.全国地下水污染防治规划(2011~2020年)[EB/OL].http://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2012/content_2121713.htm2011-10-28/2022-03-16.Ministry of Ecology and Environment.The state council on the national plan for prevention and control of groundwater pollution (2011~2020)[EB/OL].http://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2012/content_2121713.htm2011-10-28/2022-03-16.
[11] Williams J H, Paillet F L.Using flowmeter pulse tests to define hydraulic connections in the subsurface:A fractured shale example[J].Journal of Hydrology, 2002,265(1-4):100-117.
[12] Arshadi M, Rajaram H, Detwiler R L, et al.High-resolution experiments on chemical oxidation of DNAPL in variable-aperture fractures[J].Water Resources Research, 2015,51(4):2317-2335.
[13] IGRAC.The global groundwater information system (GGIS)-Extent of fissured aquifers[EB/OL].https://ggis.un-igrac.org/layers/igrac:go_aquifercracteristics_extoffissuredaquifers2020-10-27/2022-03-16.
[14] 葛锋,张转霞,扶恒,等.我国有机污染场地现状分析及展望[J].土壤, 2021,53(6):1132-1141.Ge F, Zhang Z X, Fu H, et al.Distribution of organic contaminated sites in China:Status quo and prospect[J].Soils, 2021,53(6):1132-1141.
[15] Yan Y, Dai Q, Jin L, et al.Geometric morphology and soil properties of shallow karst fissures in an area of karst rocky desertification in SW China[J].Catena, 2019,174:48-58.
[16] Li S, Ren H D, Xue L, et al.Influence of bare rocks on surrounding soil moisture in the karst rocky desertification regions under drought conditions[J].Catena, 2014,116:157-162.
[17] 中华人民共和国国务院.地下水管理条例[EB/OL].中华人民共和国国务院.http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2021-11/09/content_5649924.htm The State Council of the People's Republic of China.Regulation on groundwater management[EB/OL].http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2021-11/09/content_5649924.htm.
[18] 生态环境部.地下水污染防治实施方案[EB/OL].https://www.mee.gov.cn/xxgk2018/xxgk/xxgk03/201904/t20190401_698148.html.Ministry of Ecology and Environment.Groundwater pollution prevention and control implementation plan[EB/OL].https://www.mee.gov.cn/xxgk2018/xxgk/xxgk03/201904/t20190401_698148.html.
[19] Arnon S, Adar E, Ronen Z, et al.Biodegradation of 2,4,6-tribromophenol during transport in fractured chalk[J].Environmental Science and Technology, 2005,39(3):748-755.
[20] Dickson S E, Thomson N R.Dissolution of entrapped DNAPLs in variable aperture fractures:Experimental data and empirical model[J].Environmental Science and Technology, 2003,37(18):4128-4137.
[21] Chrysikopoulos C V, Masciopinto C, La Mantia R, et al.Removal of biocolloids suspended in reclaimed wastewater by injection into a fractured aquifer model[J].Environmental Science and Technology, 2010,44(3):971-977.
[22] ITRC.Characterization and remediation in fractured rocks[R].Interstate Technology & Regulatory Council, 2017.
[23] Suzuki A, Watanabe N, Li K, et al.Fracture network created by 3-D printer and its validation using CT images[J].Water Resources Research, 2017,53(7):6330-6339.
[24] Chen Y, Zhu X, Jiang Y, et al.Transformations and hydraulic captures of petrochemical contaminants in a karst-fractured aquifer[J].Environmental Geology, 2000,39(11):1304-1308.
[25] Goldstein K J, Vitolins A R, Navon D, et al.Characterization and pilot-scale studies for chemical oxidation remediation of fractured shale[J].Remediation, 2004,14(4):19-37.
[26] Han K, Hong U, Park S, et al.In situ field method for evaluating biodegradation potential of BTEX by indigenous heterotrophic denitrifying microorganisms in a BTEX-contaminated fractured-rock aquifer[J].Environmental Technology (United Kingdom), 2021,42(9):1326-1335.
[27] Pooley K E, Blessing M, Schmidt T C, et al.Aerobic biodegradation of chlorinated ethenes in a fractured bedrock aquifer:Quantitative assessment by compound-specific isotope analysis(CSIA)and reactive transport modeling[J].Environmental Science and Technology, 2009, 43(19):7458-7464.
[28] Schaefer C E, Lippincott D R, Klammler H, et al.Evidence of rock matrix back-diffusion and abiotic dechlorination using a field testing approach[J].Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, 2018,209:33-41.
[29] Shapiro A M, Tiedeman C R, Imbrigiotta T E, et al.Bioremediation in fractured rock:2.mobilization of chloroethene compounds from the rock matrix[J].Groundwater, 2018,56(2):317-336.
[30] Vroblesky D A, Rhodes L C, Robertson J F, et al.Locating VOC contamination in a fractured-rock aquifer at the ground-water/surface-water interface using passive vapor collectors[J].Ground Water, 1996,34(2):223-230.
[31] Arshadi M, Rajaram H.Transport with bimolecular reactions in a fracture-matrix system:analytical solutions with applications to in situ chemical oxidation[J].Water Resources Research, 2019,55(5):3904-3924.
[32] Renu V, Suresh Kumar G.Benzene dissolution and transport in a saturated sinusoidal fracture with non-uniform flow:numerical investigation and sensitivity analysis[J].Environmental Processes, 2017,4(3):587-601.
[33] Hyman J D, Painter S L, Viswanathan H, et al.Influence of injection mode on transport properties in kilometer-scale three-dimensional discrete fracture networks[J].Water Resources Research, 2015,51(9):7289-7308.
[34] Ewers R O, White K A, Fuller J F.Contaminant plumes and pseudoplumes in karst aquifers[J].Carbonates and Evaporites, 2012, 27(2):153-159.
[35] McLaren R G, Sudicky E A, Park Y J, et al.Numerical simulation of DNAPL emissions and remediation in a fractured dolomitic aquifer[J].Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, 2012,136-137:56-71.
[36] Boyer D.Soils on carbonate karst.In book:Encyclopedia of caves and karst science[M].London, UK:Taylor and Francis, 2003.
[37] Rivett M O, Wealthall G P, Dearden R A, et al.Review of unsaturated-zone transport and attenuation of volatile organic compound (VOC) plumes leached from shallow source zones[J].Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, 2011,123(3/4):130-156.
[38] Zhang Z, Chen X, Soulsby C.Catchment-scale conceptual modelling of water and solute transport in the dual flow system of the karst critical zone[J].Hydrological Processes, 2017,31(19):3421-3436.
[39] 沈欢,黄勇,苏悦,等.裂隙介质中LNAPL污染物迁移研究进展[J].环境科技, 2021,34(2):68-72.Shen H, Huang Y, Su Y, et al.Research progress on the migration of LNAPL pollutants in fractured media[J].Environmental Science and Technology, 2021,34(2):68-72.
[40] 周志芳.裂隙介质水动力学原理[M].北京:高等教育出版社, 2007.Zhou Z F.Theory on dynamics of fluids in fractured medium[M].Beijing:Higher Education Press, 2007.
[41] Wefer-Roehl A, Graber E R, Borisover M D, et al.Sorption of organic contaminants in a fractured chalk formation[J].Chemosphere, 2001, 44(5):1121-1130.
[42] Zimmerman M D, Bennett P C, Sharp Jr J M, et al.Experimental determination of sorption in fractured flow systems[J].Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, 2002,58(1/2):51-77.
[43] Lima G, Parker B, Meyer J.Dechlorinating microorganisms in a sedimentary rock matrix contaminated with a mixture of VOCs[J].Environmental Science and Technology, 2012,46(11):5756-5763.
[44] Palau J, Marchesi M, Chambon J C C, et al.Multi-isotope(carbon and chlorine)analysis for fingerprinting and site characterization at a fractured bedrock aquifer contaminated by chlorinated ethenes[J].Science of The Total Environment, 2014,475:61-70.
[45] US EPA.OSWER Technical guide for assessing and mitigating the vapor intrusion pathway from subsurface vapor sources to indoor air[R].United States Environmental Protection Agency, 2015.
[46] Barnes D L, McRae M F.The predictable influence of soil temperature and barometric pressure changes on vapor intrusion[J].Atmospheric Environment, 2017,150:15-23.
[47] You K, Zhan H.Comparisons of diffusive and advective fluxes of gas phase volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in unsaturated zones under natural conditions[J].Advances in Water Resources, 2013,52:221-231.
[48] Shirazi E, Hawk G S, Holton C W, et al.Comparison of modeled and measured indoor air trichloroethene(TCE)concentrations at a vapor intrusion site:influence of wind, temperature, and building characteristics[J].Environmental Science:Processes & Impacts, 2020, 22(3):802-811.
[49] The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine.Characterization, modeling, monitoring, and remediation of fractured rock[M].Washington D.C., USA:The National Academies Press, 2020.
[50] Chen F, Liu X, Falta R W, et al.Experimental demonstration of contaminant removal from fractured rock by boiling[J].Environmental Science and Technology, 2010,44(16):6437-6442.
[51] Fallahpour N, Mao X, Rajic L, et al.Electrochemical dechlorination of trichloroethylene in the presence of natural organic matter, metal ions and nitrates in a simulated karst media[J].Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 2017,5(1):240-245.
[52] Arnon S, Adar E, Ronen Z, et al.The effect of microbial activity on biodegradation of 2,4,6-Tribromophenol and flow in naturally fractured chalk cores[Z].2013:195-207.
[53] 侯德义.工业地块污染治理重在解决哪些问题[J].中国环境监察, 2021,6:44-46.Hou D Y.Concerns that contaminated industrial site remediation should focus on.[J].China Environment Supervision, 2021,06:44-46.
[54] Robinson J, Slater L, Johnson T, et al.Imaging pathways in fractured rock using three-dimensional electrical resistivity tomography[J].Groundwater, 2016,54(2):186-201.
[55] Jia X, O'Connor D, Shi Z, et al.VIRS based detection in combination with machine learning for mapping soil pollution[J].Environmental Pollution, 2021,268:115845.
[56] Schaefer C E.Naturally occurring dechlorination reactions in rock matrices:Impacts on TCE fate and flux[J].Environmental Technology and Innovation, 2016,6:115-122.
[57] 宋易南,侯德义,赵勇胜,等.京津冀化工场地地下水污染修复治理对策研究[J].环境科学研究, 2020,33(6):1345-1356.Song Y N, Hou D Y, Zhao Y S, et al.Remediation strategies for contaminated groundwater at chemical industrial sites in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region[J].Research of Environmental Sciences, 2020, 33(6):1345-1356.
[58] 卢斌,邵军荣,张源,等.裂隙地下水中残留LNAPL物理驱替冲洗实验[J].中国环境科学, 2020,40(1):182-189.Lu B, Shao J R, Zhang Y, et al.Physical displacement and flush of entrapped LNAPL in fractured media groundwater[J].China Environmental Science, 2020,40(1):182-189.
[59] 张丽娜,姜林,贾晓洋,等.地下水修复的技术不可达性及美国管理对策对我国的启示[J].环境科学研究, 2022,0:1-15.Zhang L N, Jiang L, Jia X Y, et al.Technical impracticability of groundwater remediation and management countermeasures in US and lessons learned for China[J].Research of Environmental Sciences, 2022,0:1-15.
[60] Limmer M, Burken J.Phytovolatilization of organic contaminants[J].Environmental Science and Technology, 2016,50(13):6632-6643.
[61] US EPA.A citizen's guide to monitored natural attenuation[R].United States Environmental Protection Agency, 2012.
[62] 朱永官,李刚,张甘霖,等.土壤安全:从地球关键带到生态系统服务[J].地理学报, 2015,70(12):1859-1869.Zhu Y G, Li G, Zhang G L, et al.Soil security:From Earth's critical zone to ecosystem services[J].Acta Geographica Sinica, 2015,70(12):1859-1869.
[63] Yao Y, Shen R, Pennell K G, et al.A review of vapor intrusion models[J].Environmental Science and Technology, 2013,47(6):2457-2470.
[64] 潘思涵,宋易南,汪军,等.耦合健康风险与生命周期评价的场地修复环境经济影响评估[J].环境科学学报, 2021,41(10):4306-4314.Pan S H, Song Y N, Wang J, et al.Coupling health risk assessment and life cycle assessment for environmental and economic impact assessment of site remediation[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae, 2021,41(10):4306-4314.
[65] Hou D.Sustainable remediation of contaminated soil and groundwater:materials, processes, and assessment[M].Oxford, UK:Elsevier, 2020.