叶菜类蔬菜产地镉环境质量类别划分技术研究

窦韦强; 安毅; 秦莉; 林大松; 董明明

PDF(477 KB)

中国环境科学 ›› 2020, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (9) : 3942-3951.

土壤污染与控制

叶菜类蔬菜产地镉环境质量类别划分技术研究

窦韦强, 安毅, 秦莉, 林大松, 董明明

作者信息 +

Study on the classification technology of the environmental quality category of cadmium in leaf vegetable production area

DOU Wei-qiang, AN Yi, QIN Li, LIN Da-song, DONG Ming-ming

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

以农业农村部环境监测总站对我国主要叶菜类蔬菜产地的例行监测数据为基础，综合考虑种类和土壤理化性质的影响，深入探讨了应用物种敏感性分布法（SSD）基于不同累积概率建立我国叶菜类蔬菜产地“优先保护类、安全利用类和严格管控类”的土壤镉环境质量类别划分阈值，并对其合理性验证.结果表明：pH值、阳离子交换量（CEC）和土壤有机质（SOM）对叶菜类蔬菜富集镉的影响均达到了极显著水平（P<0.01），并由其构建的三因子生物有效性模型为lgBCF=-0.122pH+0.025lgSOM-0.048lgCEC+1.252（R²=0.746，P<0.01，n=134），可解释叶菜类蔬菜富集系数74.6%的变异；利用上述模型将不同土壤理化性质条件下叶菜类蔬菜镉的生物富集系数（BCF）归一化处理可最大程度降低土壤理化性质对其富集镉的影响，凸出叶菜类蔬菜的内在敏感性；利用归一化后的BCF通过log-logistic拟合函数构建SSD曲线得到，不同叶菜类蔬菜种类对镉的敏感性差异明显；依据SSD曲线基于保护80%、50%和5%的叶菜类蔬菜种类分别推导出pH≤6.5、6.5<7.5及pH≥7.5时“优先保护类、安全利用类和严格管控类”的叶菜类蔬菜产地土壤镉环境质量类别划分阈值，并验证其具有一定的合理性.此方法可为我国叶菜类蔬菜产地土壤镉环境质量类别划分提供技术支撑，并为特定农产品产地土壤环境质量类别划分技术及方法的完善奠定坚实的工作基础.

Abstract

In order to establish the classification thresholds of cadmium content in the soil in the leafy vegetable production area in China, first the effects of vegetable types and soil physical and chemical properties on bioconcentration factor (BCF) was investigated. Then, the species sensitivity distribution (SSD) method was applied to develop the thresholds based on the routine monitoring data from the main vegetable production areas provided by the Agro-Environmental Monitoring Center of China. Results showed that the accumulation of cadmium in leafy vegetables were extremely and significantly influenced by soil pH, cation exchange capacity (CEC) and soil organic matter (SOM) (P<0.01). A three-factor bioavailability model was established as lg(BCF)=-0.122pH+0.025lgSOM- 0.048lgCEC+1.252(R²=0.746,P<0.01,n=134). The fitted model could explain 74.6% of the total variation in leaf vegetable enrichment. The model was then used to normalize BCF of leaf vegetable cadmium under different soil physical and chemical properties to minimize the influence of soil physical and chemical properties on cadmium accumulation, and to highlight the inherent sensitivity of leaf vegetable. The SSD curve was constructed by a log-logistic fitting function which was based on the normalized BCF. The results showed that the sensitivity of different leafy vegetables to cadmium was significant. Based on the protection rate of 80% (priority protection), 50% (safe use), and 5% (strictly control) for leafy vegetables, we derived the cadmium thresholds from SSD curves for these three categories: soil pH≤6.5, 6.5

导出引用

窦韦强, 安毅, 秦莉, 林大松, 董明明. 叶菜类蔬菜产地镉环境质量类别划分技术研究[J]. 中国环境科学. 2020, 40(9): 3942-3951

DOU Wei-qiang, AN Yi, QIN Li, LIN Da-song, DONG Ming-ming. Study on the classification technology of the environmental quality category of cadmium in leaf vegetable production area[J]. China Environmental Science. 2020, 40(9): 3942-3951

中图分类号： X53

参考文献

[1] 陈能场,郑煜基,何晓峰,等.《全国土壤污染状况调查公报》探析[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2017,36(9):1689-1692. Chen N C, Zheng Y J, He X F, et al. Analysis of the report on the national general survey of soil contamination[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science, 2017,36(9):1689-1692.
[2] 李书幻,温祝桂,陈亚茹,等.我国蔬菜重金属污染现状与对策[J]. 江苏农业科学, 2016,44(8):231-235. Li S H, Wen Z G, Chen Y R, et al. Status and countermeasures of heavy metal pollution in vegetables in China[J]. Jiangsu Agricultural Sciences, 2016,44(8):231-235.
[3] Li J X, Liu M D, Zhang W, et al. Evaluation and source analysis on heavy metal pollution of vegetable garden soil in the urban-rural area of Fushun city[J]. Advanced Materials Research, 2012,518-523:2121-2129.
[4] Gu J, Liu Z X. Investigation and evaluation on heavy metal pollution of vegetable farm soils in Fuxin, China[J]. Advanced Materials Research, 2014,955-959:3661-3664.
[5] 赵勇,李红娟,孙治强,等.郑州农区土壤重金属污染与蔬菜质量相关性探析[J]. 中国生态农业学报, 2006,14(4):126-130. Zhao Y, Li H J, Sun Z Q, et al. Correlation between the heavy metal pollution in soil and quality of vegetable in farming district of Zhengzhou[J]. Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture, 2006,14(4):126-130.
[6] 梁称福,陈正法,刘明月.蔬菜重金属污染研究进展[J]. 湖南农业科学, 2002,(4):45-48. Liang C F, Chen Z F, Liu M Y. Study processes on heavy metal pollution on vegetables[J]. Hunan Agricultural Sciences, 2002,(4):45-48.
[7] 赵小蓉,杨谢,陈光辉,等.成都平原区不同蔬菜品种对重金属富集能力研究[J]. 西南农业学报, 2010,(4):164-168. Zhao X R, Yang X, Chen G H, et al. Assessment of heavy metal enrichment in vegetables of Chengdu plain[J]. Southwest Agricultural Journal, 2010,(4):164-168.
[8] 赵亚玲.土壤蔬菜中铅镉污染评价与富集特征研究[J]. 蔬菜, 2018,336(12):66-70. Zhao Y L. Evaluation and enrichment of lead and cadmium pollution in soil vegetables[J]. Vegetables, 2018,336(12):66-70.
[9] 万家悦,彭位华,贺希格都楞,等.镉在典型蔬菜可食部位富集特征及其健康风险评价[J]. 中国计量大学报, 2019,30(2):255-264. Wan J Y, Peng W H, He X G D L, et al. Characteristics of cadmium enrichment in edible parts of typical vegetables and its health risk assessment[J]. Journal of China Jiliang University, 2019,30(2):255-264.
[10] Al-Othman Z A, Ali R, Al-Othman A M, et al. Assessment of toxic metals in wheat crops grown on selected soils, irrigated by different water sources[J]. Arabian Journal of Chemistry, 2012,9(2):1555-1562.
[11] Liu Y, Chen M, Jiang L, et al. Erratum to:New insight into molecular interaction of heavy metal pollutant-cadmium(II) with human serum albumin[J]. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2016, 23(5):4959-4959.
[12] 李发生.土壤污染防治行动计划[J]. 农村实用技术, 2016,(10):5-12. Li F S. Soil pollution prevention action plan[J]. Rural Practical Technology, 2016,(10):5-12.
[13] 窦韦强,安毅,秦莉,等.农用地土壤重金属生态安全阈值确定方法的研究进展[J]. 生态毒理学报, 2019,14(4):54-64. Dou W Q, An Y, Qin L, et al. Research progress in determination methods of ecological safety thresholds for heavy metals in agricultural land[J]. Journal of Ecotoxicology, 2019,14(4):54-64.
[14] 曾庆楠,安毅,秦莉,等.物种敏感性分布法在建立土壤生态阈值方面的研究进展[J]. 安全与环境报, 2018,18(3):1220-1224. Zeng Q N, An Y, Qin L, et al. Advances on species sensitivity distribution in deriving soil ecological thresholds[J]. Journal of Safety and Environment, 2018,18(3):1220-1224.
[15] 雷丽萍,刘彬,陈世宝,等.不同烟草对Cd吸收的敏感性分布及烟草中Cd的结合形态[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2015,34(10):1858-1864. Lei L P, Liu B, Chen S B, et al. Cd-phytotoxicity species sensitivity distributions and root Cd forms of different tobacco cultivars[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science, 2015,34(10):1858-1864.
[16] 孙聪,陈世宝,宋文恩,等.不同品种水稻对土壤中镉的富集特征及敏感性分布(SSD)[J]. 中国农业科学, 2014,47(12):2384-2394. Sun C, Chen S B, Song W E, et al. Accumulation characteristics of cadmium by rice cultivars in soils and its species sensitivity distributions[J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2014,47(12):2384-2394.
[17] 孙聪,陈世宝,马义兵,等.基于物种敏感性分布(Burr-Ⅲ)模型预测Cd对水稻毒害的生态风险阈值HC₅[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2013,32(12):2316-2322. Sun C, Chen S B, MaY B, et al. Ecological hazard concentration (HC₅) of cadmium(Cd)to rice cultivars under hydroponic culture as determined with species sensitivity distribution model(Burr-Ⅲ)[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science, 2013,32(12):2316-2322.
[18] Niu Z, Du L, Li J, et al. Ecological risk assessment of microcystin-LR in the upstream section of the Haihe river based on a species sensitivity distribution model[J]. Chemosphere, 2018,193:403-411.
[19] Straalen N M V, Posthuma L. Theory of ecological risk assessment based on species sensitivity distributions[J]. Palaeogeography Palaeoclimatology Palaeoecology, 2002,175(4):249-272.
[20] GB 2762-2017食品安全国家标准食品中污染物限量[S]. GB 2762-2017 National food safety standard limits of contaminants in food[S].
[21] 陈青云,张晶,谭启玲,等.4种磷肥对土壤-叶菜类蔬菜系统中镉生物有效性的影响[J]. 华中农业大学学报, 2013,32(1):78-82. Chen Q Y, Zhang J, Tan Q L, et al. Effects of four phosphorus fertilizers on cadmium bioavailability in soil-leaf vegetables systems[J]. Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University, 2013,32(1):78-82.
[22] Ci D, Jiang D, Liu F, et al. Comparisons of cadmium tolerance and accumulation at seedling stage in wheat varieties grown in different decades in China[J]. Acta Physiologiae Plantarum, 2011,33(5):1811-1819.
[23] 沈欣,朱奇宏,朱捍华,等.农艺调控措施对水稻镉积累的影响及其机理研究[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2015,34(8):1449-1454. Shen X, Zhu Q H, Zhu H H, et al. Effects of agronomic measures on accumulation of Cd in rice[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science, 2015,34(8):1449-1454.
[24] 赵云青,周怡,黄兴洁,等.重金属在矿区土壤——蔬菜系统的吸收与迁移特性研究[J]. 土壤通报, 2019,50(5):1233-1238. Zhao Y Q, Zhou Y, Huang X J, et al. Absorption and migration of heavy metals in soil-vegetable system in mining area[J]. Soil Bulletin, 2019,50(5):1233-1238.
[25] 王秀梅.基于二次判别模型(QDA)的土壤镉安全阈值判定[D]. 北京:中国农业科学院, 2018. Wang X M. Determination of soil cadmium safety threshold based on quadratic discriminant model (QDA)[D]. Beijing:Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, 2018.
[26] 石一珺,徐颖菲,倪中应,等.杭州市主要农作物对镉的富集差异及其影响因素[J]. 浙江农业科学, 2019,60(7):1230-1233. Shi Y J, Xu Y F, Ni Z Y, et al. Enrichment coefficients of cadmium in main crops in Hangzhou region and its influencing factors[J]. Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2019,60(7):1230-1233.
[27] 张帆,谢玲玲,弥宝彬,等.蔬菜对重金属镉富集研究进展[J]. 湖南农业科学, 2017,(7):127-130. Zhang F, Xie L L, Mi B B, et al. Research progress on heavy metal cadmium enrichment in vegetables[J]. Hunan Agricultural Science, 2017,(7):127-130.
[28] 杨阳,李艳玲,陈卫平,等.蔬菜镉(Cd)富集因子变化特征及其影响因素[J]. 环境科学, 2017,38(1):399-404. Yang Y, Li Y L, Chen W P, et al. Variation characteristics of vegetables cadmium uptake factors and its relations to environmental factors[J]. Environmental Science, 2017,38(1):399-404.
[29] 王小庆,韦东普,黄占斌,等.物种敏感性分布法在土壤中铜生态阈值建立中的应用研究[J]. 环境科学学报, 2013,33(6):1787-1794. Wang X Q, Wei D P, Huang Z B, et al. Application of species sensitivity distribution in deriving of ecological thresholds for copper in soils[J]. Journal of Environmental Science, 2013,33(6):1787-1794.
[30] 王小庆,韦东普,黄占斌,等.物种敏感性分布在土壤中镍生态阈值建立中的应用研究[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2012,31(1):92-98. Wang X Q, Wei D P, Huang Z B, et al. Application of species sensitivity distribution in deriving of ecological thresholds for nickel in soils[J]. Journal of Agricultural Environmental Sciences, 2012, 31(1):92-98.
[31] Hickey G L, Craig P S. Competing statistical methods for the fitting of normal species sensitivity distributions:recommendations for practitioners[J]. Risk Analysis, 2012,32(7):1232-1243.
[32] 杜建国,赵佳懿,陈彬,等.应用物种敏感性分布评估重金属对海洋生物的生态风险[J]. 生态毒理学报, 2013,8(4):561-570. Du J G, Zhao J Y, Chen B, et al. Assessing ecological risks of heavy metals to marine organisms by species sensitivity distributions[J]. Journal of Ecotoxicology, 2013,8(4):561-570.
[33] 程菁靓,赵龙,杨彦,等.我国长江中下游水稻产区铅污染分区划分方法研究[J]. 农业环境科学学报, 2019,38(1):70-78. Cheng J L, Zhao L, Yang Y, et al. Classification methods for typical lead-contaminated rice production areas of the middle and lower Yangtze River in China[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science, 2019,38(1):70-78.
[34] 颜世红.酸化土壤中镉化学形态特征与钝化研究[D]. 淮南:安徽理工大学, 2013. Yan S H. Study on the chemical form and passivation of cadmium in acidified soil[D]. Huainan:Anhui University of Science and Technology, 2013.
[35] 王一志,曹雪莹,谭长银,等.不同土壤pH对红壤稻田镉形态及水稻镉积累的影响[J]. 湖南师范大学自然科学学报, 2017,40(1):10-16. Wang Y Z, Cao X Y, Tan C Y, et al. Effects of different soil pH on cadmium fractions and cadmium accumulation in rice[J]. Journal of Natural Science of Hunan Normal University, 2017,40(1):10-16.
[36] 罗文贱,张政勤,陈勇,等.连续解吸中离子强度对可变电荷土壤和高岭石体系pH的影响[J]. 土壤学报, 2016,53(1):146-154. Luo W C, Zhang Z Q, Chen Y, et al. Effect of ionic-strength change on the system pH of variable charge soils and kaolinite during successive desorption[J]. Acta Soila Sinica, 2016,53(1):146-154.
[37] Salati S, Quadri G, Tambone F, et al. Fresh organic matter of municipal solid waste enhances phytoextraction of heavy metals from contaminated soil[J]. Environmental pollution, 2010,158(5):1899-1906.
[38] Hooda P S, Alloway B J. Cadmium and lead sorption behaviour of selected English and Indian soils[J]. Geoderma, 1998,84(3):121-134.
[39] 张磊,宋凤斌.土壤吸附重金属的影响因素研究现状及展望[J]. 土壤通报, 2005,36(4):628-631. Zhang L, Song F B. Adsorption of heavy metals by soils and its affecting factors[J]. Soil Bulletin, 2005,36(4):628-631.
[40] 史明易,王祖伟,王嘉宝,等.基于富集系数对蔬菜地土壤重金属的安全阈值研究[J]. 干旱区资源与环境, 2020,34(2):130-134. Shi M Y, Wang Z W, Wang J B, et al. Study on safety threshold of heavy metals in vegetable soils based on bioaccumulation factor[J]. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment, 2020,34(2):130-134.
[41] Ding C, Ma Y, Li X, et al. Determination and validation of soil thresholds for cadmium based on food quality standard and health risk assessment[J]. Science of The Total Environment, 2018,619-620:700-706.
[42] 王卫,梁振飞,李菊梅,等.土壤性质对烟草中镉富集的影响及预测模型研究[J]. 土壤, 2014,46(1):178-183. Wang W, Liang Z F, Li J M, et al. Studies on effects of soil properties on Cd accumulation in tobacco and prediction model[J]. Soils, 2014,46(1):178-183.
[43] 杨阳,王美娥,李艳玲,等.基于转移方程的蔬菜镉累积预测和土壤风险阈值推导[J]. 应用生态学报, 2017,28(2):603-608. Yang Y, Wang M E, Li Y L, et al. Prediction of Cd in vegetables and soil Cd threshold derivation based on transfer function[J]. Journal of Applied Ecology, 2017,28(2):603-608.
[44] 王彦斌,杨一鸣,曾亮,等.甘肃省榆中县菜地土壤与蔬菜中重金属含量及健康风险评估[J]. 干旱地区农业研究, 2015,33(6):234-241. Yan B, Yang Y M, Zeng L, et al. A survey of heavy metals concentrations in vegetables and soils in Yuzhong County of Gansu Province and their health risk[J]. Agriculture Research in the Arid Areas, 2015,33(6):234-241.
[45] 冯艳红,王国庆,张亚,等.土壤-蔬菜系统中镉的生物富集效应及土壤阈值研究[J]. 地球与环境, 2019,47(5):653-661. Feng Y H, Wang G Q, Zhang Y, et al. Study on bioaccumulation of cadmium in soil-vegetable system and pollution threshold in soil[J]. Earth and Environment, 2019,47(5):653-661.
[46] Ding C, Ma Y, Li X, et al. Derivation of soil thresholds for lead applying species sensitivity distribution:A case study for root vegetables[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 2015,303:21-27.
[47] 刘克.我国主要小麦产地土壤镉和铅的安全阈值研究[D]. 杨凌:西北农林科技大学, 2016. Liu K. Study on the safety threshold of soil cadmium and lead in wheat production areas in China[D]. Yangling:Northwest A & F University, 2016.
[48] 孙在金,赵淑婷,林祥龙,等.基于物种敏感度分布法建立中国土壤中锑的环境基准[J]. 环境科学研究, 2018,31(4):774-781. Sun Z J, Zhao S T, Lin X L, et al. Deriving soils environmental criteria of antimony in china by species sensitivity distributions[J]. Environmental Science Research, 2018,31(4):774-781.
[49] 邹素敏,杜瑞英,文典,等.不同品种蔬菜重金属污染评价和富集特征研究[J]. 生态环境学报, 2017,26(4):714-720. Zou S M, Du R Y, Wen D, et al. Enrichment characteristics analysis and assessment on heavy metal contamination of different vegetables[J]. Journal of Eco-Environment, 2017,26(4):714-720.
[50] 林君锋,高树芳,陈伟平,等.蔬菜对土壤镉铜锌富集能力的研究[J]. 土壤与环境, 2002,(3):248-251. Lin J F, Gao S F, Chen W P, et al. Study on the enrichment capacity of vegetables for soil cadmium, copper and zinc[J]. Soil and Environment, 2002,(3):248-251.
[51] GB15618-2018土壤环境质量农用地土壤污染风险管控标准[S]. GB15618-2018 Soil environmental quality risk control standard for soil contamination of agricultural land[S].
[52] 文典,刘香香,王其枫,等.菜薹(菜心)对土壤中重金属的富集特征及产地土壤安全临界值[J]. 中国蔬菜, 2012,(12):89-96. Wen D, Liu X X, Wang Q F, et al. Heavy metal accumulation characteristics and environmental cri tical values in flowering cabbage(Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis (L.) var. utilis Tsen et Lee)production area for food security[J]. China Vegetable, 2012, (12):89-96.