Characteristics and risk assessment of surface water fluorine pollution in Ningxia section of Yellow River Basin
ZHAO Zeng-feng1, FU Yong-liang1, QIU Xiao-cong2, ZHOU Rui-juan3, ZHAO Rui-zhi1, YANG Qiang-qiang1
1. School of Civil and Hydraulic Engineering, Ningxia University, Yinchuan 750021, China; 2. School of Life Science, Ningxia University, Yinchuan 750021, China; 3. Ningxia Environment Monitoring Center, Yinchuan 750000, China
Abstract：In spring (April), summer (July) and autumn (October) of 2019 and 2021, six times were collected at 99 points in the Ningxia section of the Yellow River Basin. The 99 points were divided into 8 water systems which including the main stream of the Yellow River (S1), Qingshui River (S2), Kushui River (S3), Drainage ditch on the north bank of the Yellow River in Weining Section (S4), drainage ditch on the south bank of the Yellow River in Weining Section (S5), drainage ditch on the west bank of the Yellow River in Qingshi Section (S6), drainage ditch on the east bank of the Yellow River in Qingshi Section (S7), and urban landscape River and lake (S8), and the temporal and spatial distribution of fluorine was analyzed, the influence of environmental factors on fluorine enrichment was analyzed, and ecological and health risk assessment was carried out. The results showed that the average fluoride concentration of surface water in Ningxia section of the Yellow River Basin was 1.46mg/L, higher than the standard value of drinking water in China (1.0mg/L). Influenced by evaporation concentration and rainfall dilution, the fluorine concentration changed from high to low in autumn, spring and summer. The exceeding fluorine was the most serious in the Kushui River, Qingshui River and drainage ditch on the east bank of the Yellow River in Qingshi Section, and the main stream of the Yellow River was the only water system that was not polluted by fluoride. The average ecological risk of surface water fluoride in Ningxia section of the Yellow River Basin reached the low risk level, and the medium risk ratio was 27.84% in autumn, 22.33% in spring, and 11.11% in summer. The highest ecological risk of fluoride was found in the Kushui River, with the medium risk ratio reaching 80%. The results of the health risk assessment showed that except for the main stream of the Yellow River, other seven water systems posed health risks to both children and adults, and the harm to children was much greater than that to adults. The temporal and spatial distribution of fluorine was mainly affected by natural factors, and the dissolution of evaporite weathering and evaporation concentration were the main factors of fluorine enrichment in this area.
赵增锋, 付永亮, 邱小琮, 周瑞娟, 赵睿智, 杨强强. 黄河流域宁夏段地表水氟污染特征与风险评价[J]. 中国环境科学, 2023, 43(11): 5800-5811.
ZHAO Zeng-feng, FU Yong-liang, QIU Xiao-cong, ZHOU Rui-juan, ZHAO Rui-zhi, YANG Qiang-qiang. Characteristics and risk assessment of surface water fluorine pollution in Ningxia section of Yellow River Basin. CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCECE, 2023, 43(11): 5800-5811.
吴卫红.土-水-气界面间氟的迁移机理及其生态效应[D]. 杭州:浙江大学, 2002. Wu W H. Migration mechanism and ecological effect of fluorine at soil-water-air interface [D]. Hangzhou:Zhejiang University, 2002.
[2]
Katiyar P, Pandey N, Sahu K K. Biological approaches of fluoride remediation:potential for environmental clean-up [J]. Environmental science and pollution research international, 2020,27(12):13044-13055.
[3]
Calero P, Gurdo N, Nikel P I. Role of the CrcB transporter of Pseudomonas putida in the multi-level stress response elicited by mineral fluoride [J]. Environmental microbiology, 2022, 24(11):5082-5104.
[4]
Mukherjee I, Singh U K. Exploring a variance decomposition approach integrated with the Monte Carlo method to evaluate groundwater fluoride exposure on the residents of a typical fluorosis endemic semi-arid tract of India [J]. Environmental Research, 2022, 203:111697.
[5]
王根绪,程国栋.西北干旱区水中氟的分布规律及环境特征[J]. 地理科学, 2000,(2):153-159. Wang G X, Cheng G D. Distribution and environmental characteristics of fluoride in water in arid area of Northwest China [J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2000,(2):153-159.
[6]
李凤嫣,蒋天宇,余涛,等.环境中氟的来源及健康风险评估研究进展[J]. 岩矿测试, 2021,40(6):793-807. Li F Y, Jiang T Y, Xu T, et al. Review on sources of fluorine in the environment and health risk assessment [J]. Rock and Mineral Analysis, 2021,40(6):793-807.
[7]
Amini M, Mueller K, Abbaspour K C, et al. Statistical modeling of global geogenic fluoride contamination in groundwaters [J]. Environmental Science & Technology, 2008,42(10):3662-3668.
[8]
荆秀艳,李小珍,王文姬,等.银川平原地下水中氟分布特征及健康风险评价[J]. 环境科学与技术, 2022,45(2):174-181. Jing X Y, Li X Z, Wang W J, et al. Distribution characteristics and health risk assessment of fluorine in groundwater in Yinchuan Plain [J]. Environmental Science and Technology, 2022,45(2):174-181.
[9]
邰苏日嘎拉,李永春,周文辉,等.宁夏固原市原州区高氟地区氟对人体健康的影响[J]. 岩矿测试, 2021,40(6):919-929. Tai S R G L, Li Y C, Zhou W H, et al. Effect of fluorine on human health in high-fluorine areas in Yuanzhou District, Guyuan City, Ningxia Autonomous Region [J]. Rock and Mineral Analysis, 2021, 40(6):919-929.
[10]
陈萍,鲁青,姜泓,等.果洛州地方性氟骨症流行现状分析[J]. 中国地方病防治, 2023,38(2):110-112. Chen P, Lu Q, Jiang H, et al. Analysis of endemic skeletal fluorosis in Guoluo Prefecture [J]. Chinese Journal of Control of Endemic Diseases, 2023,38(2):110-112.
[11]
刘靖宇,赫银峰,耿建阳,等.典型干旱区绿洲土壤氟的迁移富集及健康风险评价[J]. 中国地质, 2023:1-16. Liu J Y, He Y F, Geng J Y, et al. Migration, enrichment and health risk assessment of soil fluoride in typical arid region of oasis [J]. Geology in China, 2023:1-16.
[12]
李渊.汾河流域饮用水源中氟和砷的分布特征及土地利用和植被变化的影响[D]. 太原:山西大学, 2020. Li Y. Distribution characteristics of fluorine and arsenic in drinking water sources and their effects on land use and vegetation change in Fenhe River Basin. Taiyuan:Shanxi University, 2020.
[13]
黄彤彤,王文台,杨俊林,等.食用燃煤烘烤后含氟辣椒中氟的人体吸收和健康风险阈值[J]. 生态毒理学报, 2023:1-12. Huang T T, Wang W T, Yang J L, et al. Human absorption and health risk threshold of fluoride in fluorinated capsicum after roasting with edible coal [J]. Chinese Journal of Ecotoxicology, 2023:1-12.
[14]
王渊钊.黄河流域宁夏段生态环境保护与高质量发展耦合协调度研究[D]. 兰州:西北民族大学, 2022. Wang Y Z. Study on coupling coordination degree of ecological environment protection and high quality development in Ningxia section of Yellow River Basin [D]. Lanzhou:Northwest University for Nationalities, 2022.
[15]
于丽萍,孙静,陈阿丽,等.2014年宁夏饮水型地方性氟中毒情况分析[J]. 宁夏医科大学学报, 2017,39(3):290-292. Yu L P, Sun J, Chen A L, et al. Drinking water type endemic fluorosis in monitoring data of Ningxia in 2014[J]. Journal of Ningxia Medical University, 2017,39(3):290-292.
[16]
杨亚丽,王建英,缑晓辉,等.宁夏旅游气候舒适度时空特征分析[J]. 宁夏大学学报(自然科学版), 2021,42(1):88-94. Yang Y L, Wang J Y, Gou X H, et al. Spatial and temporal characteristics of tourism climate comfort in Ningxia [J]. Journal of Ningxia University (Natural Science Edition), 2021,42(1):88-94.
[17]
曾建军,邹明亮,郭建军,等.生态风险评价研究进展综述[J]. 环境监测管理与技术, 2017,29(1):1-5. Zeng J J, Zou M L, Guo J J, et al. Ecological risk assessment and its research progress [J]. Environmental Monitoring Management and Technology, 2017,29(1):1-5.
[18]
Liu X, Tu M, Wang S, et al. Research on freshwater water quality criteria, sediment quality criteria and ecological risk assessment of triclosan in China [J]. The Science of the Total Environment. 2021, 816:151616.
[19]
郑丽萍,龙涛,邓绍坡,等.我国氟化物的淡水水生生物基准研究[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2015,31(6):923-927. Zheng L P, Long T, Deng S P, et al. Biological criteria of fluoride for freshwater hydrobiont in China [J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2015,31(6):923-927.
[20]
GB 3838-2002地表水环境质量标准[S]. 北京:中国标准出版社, 2002. GB 2762-2005 Environmental quality standards for surface water [S]. Beijing:Standards Press of China, 2002.
[21]
刘宛昕,刘思彤,穆迪,等.渤海湾锌海水水质基准推导及潜在生态风险评价[J]. 环境化学, 2023:1-12. Liu W X, Liu S T, Mu D, et al. Derivation and potential ecological risk assessment of zinc seawater in Bohai Bay [J]. Environmental Chemistry, 2023:1-12.
[22]
宋晓光,芦岩,梁仕凯,等.张家口坝下地区高氟地下水成因分析与健康风险评价[J]. 地质科技通报, 2022,41(1):240-250. Song X G, Lu Y, Liang S K, et al. Analysis of high-fluoride groundwater formation mechanisms and assessment of health risk in Baxia region, Zhangjiakou [J]. Bulletin of Geological Science and Technology, 2022,41(1):240-250.
[23]
Usepa. Available information on assessment exposure from pesticides in food [R]. Washington D C:U.S.Programs, Environmental Protection Agency Office, 2000.
[24]
Wang W Z, Li Z, Su H, et al. Spatial and seasonal variability, control factors and health risk of fluoride in natural water in the Loess Plateau of China [J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 2022,434:128897.
[25]
徐海明,刘明月,田华,等.宁夏吴忠地区饮用水氟健康风险评价[J]. 环境与健康杂志, 2017,34(8):715-716 Xu H M, Liu M Y, Tian H, et al. Health risk assessment of drinking water fluoride in Wuzhong district of Ningxia [J]. Journal of Environment and Health, 2017,34(8):715-716.
[26]
Jianping Z, Hongmei W, Charles A C I, et al. Dissolution of fluorapatite by Pseudomonas fluorescens P35 resulting in fluorine Release [J]. Geomicrobiology Journal, 2016,34(5):421-433.
[27]
单阳阳,李正炎.基于盐度校正法的中国河口铅水生生物水质基准制定[J]. 生态毒理学报, 2020,15(5):272-287. Shan Y Y, Li Z Y. Derivation of water quality criteria of lead for the protection of chinese estuarine species based on salinity correction method [J]. Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology, 2020,15(5):272-287.
[28]
马超群,李正炎,胡泓,等.基于盐度校正的中国河口铜水生生物水质基准研究[J]. 中国海洋大学学报(自然科学版), 2023,53(3):82-97. Ma C Q, Li Z Y, Hu H, et al. Study of water quality criteria of copper for the protection of Chinese estuarine species based on salinity correction method [J]. Periodical of Ocean University of China, 2023,53(3):82-97.
[29]
于建渤,黄学聃,陈欢,等.不同盐度条件下氨氮对斑节对虾仔虾的毒性研究[J]. 水产养殖, 2023,44(4):16-21. Yu J B, Huang X D, Chen H, et al. Toxicity of ammonia nitrogen on Penaeus Monodon larvae under different salinity conditions [J]. Journal of Aquaculture, 2023,44(4):16-21.
[30]
崔宇航,黄学聃,陈欢,等.不同盐度条件下亚硝酸盐氮对斑节对虾仔虾的毒性研究[J]. 水产养殖, 2022,43(11):1-5. Cui Y H, Huang X D, Chen H, et al. Toxicity of nitrite nitrogen on Penaeus Monodon larvae under different salinity conditions [J]. Journal of Aquaculture, 2022,43(11):1-5.
[31]
GB 2762-2005食物中污染物的限量标准[S]. 北京:中国标准出版社, 2005. GB 2762-2005 Standard for limits of contaminants in food [S]. Beijing:Standards Press of China, 2005.
[32]
Jun X, Zhangdong J, Fei Z. Geochemical controls on fluoride concentrations in natural waters from the middle Loess Plateau, China [J]. Journal of Geochemical Exploration, 2015,159:252-261.
[33]
Meththika V, Prosun B. Fluoride in the environment:Sources, distribution and defluoridation [J]. Environmental Chemistry Letters, 2015,13(2):131-147.
[34]
Anirban C, Mrinal K A, Arnab M, et al. A critical review on geochemical and geological aspects of fluoride belts, fluorosis and natural materials and other sources for alternatives to fluoride exposure [J]. Journal of Hydrology, 2019,574:333-359.
[35]
Liu Y, Zhu W H. Environmental characteristics of regional groundwater in relation to fluoride poisoning in North China [J]. Environmental Geology and Water Sciences, 1991,18(1).
[36]
何锦,张福存,韩双宝,等.中国北方高氟地下水分布特征和成因分析[J]. 中国地质, 2010,37(3):621-626. He J, Zhang F C, Han S B, et al. The distribution and genetic types of high-fluoride groundwater in northern China [J]. Geology in China, 2010,37(3):621-626.
[37]
刘白薇.半干旱区水文地球化学演化规律及成因研究——以土默川平原为例[D]. 武汉:中国地质大学, 2019. Liu B W. Study on hydrogeochemical evolution and its genesis in semi-arid region:A case study of Tumochuan Plain [D]. Wuhan:China University of Geosciences, 2019.
[38]
嵇晓燕,李波,杨凯,等.中国地表水氟化物时空分布特征初步研究[J]. 地球与环境, 2022,50(6):787-796. Ji X Y, Li B, Yang K, et al. Spatial and temporal distribution characteristics of fluoride in surface water of China [J]. Earth and Environment, 2022,50(6):787-796.
[39]
谢殿荣.宁夏地下水原生氟污染空间分布预测[J]. 安全与环境工程, 2022,29(6):149-155. Xie D R. Spatial distribution prediction of primary fluoride pollution in groundwater in Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region [J]. Safety and Environmental Engineering, 2022,29(6):149-155.
[40]
王连方,孙幸之,杨成忠,等.新疆奎屯一乌苏山前倾斜平原地方性氟中毒的地理分布规律[J]. 中国地方病学杂志, 1982,(4):35-39. Wang L F, Sun X Z, Yang C Z, et al. Geographical distribution of endemic fluorosis in the front sloping plain of Kuitun-Wusu Mountain, Xinjiang [J]. Chinese Journal of Local Epidemiology, 1982,(4):35-39.
[41]
穆敏,李王成,王洁,等.宁夏中部干旱带粗颗粒土裂化过程研究[J]. 东北农业大学学报, 2022,53(6):88-96. Mu M, Li W C, Wang J, et al. Study on cracking process of coarse-grained soils in central dry zone of Ningxia [J]. Journal of Northeast Agricultural University, 2022,53(6):88-96.
[42]
张晓燕,张春霞,李佩.青藏高原东缘若尔盖盆地表层沉积物粘土矿物组成及其环境意义探讨[J]. 第四纪研究, 2022,42(2):435-448. Zhang X Y, Zhang C X, Li P. Composition and environmental significance of clay minerals in surface sediments of Ruoergai Basin, eastern margin of Qinghai-Tibet Plateau [J]. Quaternary Sciences. 2022,42(2):435-448.
[43]
刘敏,赵良元,李青云,等.长江源区主要河流水化学特征、主要离子来源[J]. 中国环境科学, 2021,41(3):1243-1254. Liu M, Zhao L Y, LiQ Y, et al. Hydrochemical characteristics, main ion sources of main rivers in the source region of Yangtze River [J]. China Environmental Science, 2021,41(3):1243-1254.
[44]
邹嘉文,刘飞,张靖坤.南水北调典型受水区浅层地下水水化学特征及成因[J]. 中国环境科学, 2022,42(5):2260-2268. Zou J W, Liu F, Zhang J K. Hydrochemical characteristics and formation mechanism of shallow groundwater in typical water-receiving areas of the South-to-North Water Diversion Project [J]. China Environmental Science, 2022,42(5):2260-2268
[45]
Mukherjee I, Singh U K. Groundwater fluoride contamination, probable release, and containment mechanisms:A review on Indian context [J]. Environmental Geochemistry and Health, 2018,40(6):2259-2301.
[46]
Guo Q H, Wang Y X, Ma T, et al. Geochemical processes controlling the elevated fluoride concentrations in groundwaters of the Taiyuan basin, Northern China [J]. Journal of Geochemical Exploration, 2007, 93(1):1-12.
[47]
Rasool A, Farooqi A, Xiao T F, et al. A review of global outlook on fluoride contamination in groundwater with prominence on the Pakistan current situation [J]. Environmental Geochemistry and Health, 2018,40(4):1265-1281.
[48]
王建,韩海东,许君利,等.塔里木河流域出山径流水化学特征研究[J]. 中国环境科学, 2021,41(4):1576-1587. Wang J, Han H D, Xu J L, et al. Hydrochemical characteristics of the mountain runoff in Tarim River Basin, China [J]. China Environmental Science, 2021,41(4):1576-1587.
[49]
曹小虎.涑水盆地高氟地下水的分布及成因分析[J]. 中国水运(下半月), 2011,11(8):190-191. Cao X H. Distribution and origin analysis of high-fluorine groundwater in the Sushui Basin [J]. China Water Transport (Second Half), 2011,11(8):190-191.
[50]
邵琳琳,杨胜科,王文科,等.奎屯河流域水土中氟的分布规律[J]. 地球科学与环境学报, 2006,(4):64-68. Shao L L, Yang S K, Wang W K, et al. Distribution regularity of fluorine in shallow groundwater in unsaturated soils of Kuitun River Basin, Xinjiang [J]. Journal of Earth Sciences and Environment, 2006,(4):64-68.
[51]
Liu Q, Li Y, Li W, et al. Effect of the release of gravel elements on soil nutrients and Jujube Fruit Yield under wet-and-dry cycles [J]. Agronomy, 2022,12(11):2881.
[52]
罗文婷,张鑫,高旭波.运城盆地人类活动氟污染的环境效应研究[J]. 安全与环境工程, 2017,24(2):46-52. Luo W T, Zhang X, Gao X B. Impact of human activities on environmental fluoride pollution in Yuncheng Basin [J]. Safety and Environmental Engineering, 2017,24(2):46-52.
[53]
Sujay S K, Gene E L, Michael L P, et al. Freshwater salinization syndrome:from emerging global problem to managing risks [J]. Biogeochemistry, 2021,154(2):255-292.
[54]
汪生斌,祁泽学,王万平,等.格尔木河水化学特征及成因[J]. 水资源保护, 2020,36(5):93-98. Wang S B, Qi Z X, Wang W W, et al. Hydrochemical characteristics and causes of formation of the Golmud River [J]. Water Resources Protection, 2020,36(5):93-98.
[55]
韩占涛,张发旺,桂建业,等.盐池地区高氟地下水成因与低氟水找水方向研究[J]. 干旱区资源与环境, 2009,23(12):151-156. Han Z T, Zhang F W, Gui J Y, et al. Research on the genesis of high-fluoride groundwater in Yanchi area and direction for low-fluoride groundwater prospect [J]. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment, 2009,23(12):151-156.
